History

im writing an essay on the mexican and american war how is this?

The Mexican-American War was a conflict between the United States and Mexico. It commenced on 25 April, 1846 and ended on 2 February, 1848. President Polk played a large role in the United States government's involvement with the Mexican-American War. Not all American citizens supported the war. There were many individuals who were against to it. Henry David Thoreau, an American writer and philosopher, strongly opposed the war by declaring the United States actions as unethical.
The Mexican-American War was a result of Manifest Destiny. , Manifest Destiny was a belief that Americans had a god given right to expand their border all the way to the Pacific Ocean. Not only did Americans believe that they had a right to the land, but they also believed that they had a moral duty to civilize its occupants, which included Native Americans, Mexicans, and Spanish speaking Catholics. According to Encyclopedia Britannica, the Mexican-American War originated from the United States annexation of Texas in 1845 ("Mexican-American War"). Texas had been in a border dispute with Mexico at the time of the annexation; therefore, the conflict transferred to the U.S. Mexico claimed that the border ended at the Nueces River, and the United States claimed it ended at the Rio Grande River.
In 1844, James Polk won the presidential election by campaigning on the idea of expanding the American border to the Pacific Ocean. David A. Clary, author of Eagles and Empires, asserts that Polk's "territorial ambitions were naked and unashamed and there was never any hesitation on ethical grounds" (64). With no type of military training or experience, Polk kept control over the bigger strategies of the Army and Navy forces before and during the war. He knew that Mexico was in political turmoil, had a limited budget for its military, and had problems getting supplies to its troops. With this information, Polk planned his military strategies accordingly. Mark Crawford, author of Encyclopedia of the Mexican-American War, to "entrust public business to his subordinates" (218). Polk was determined to expand the U.S. borders and nothing would have stopped him from doing so.
One of Polk's first actions that led to the war was to send Congressman John Slidell to Mexico in 1848. Slidell was to offer Mexico thirty million dollars to buy its Northern Territories, which included present day California, Nevada, Utah, parts of Arizona, New Mexico, Colorado, and Wyoming. According to The U.S. Mexican War, a documentary distributed by PBS, Mexico rejected Slidell and refused to negotiate with the United States. Not happy with the refusal, Polk ordered troops to the Rio Grade knowing it was the disputed territory between the U.S. and Mexico. Once the troops reached the Rio Grande, they built a fortress named Fort Texas. Tensions immediately rose between the two countries. Polk had hoped that Mexico would feel intimidated by the American soldiers' presence and would agree to sell their Northern Territories to the United States. If intimidation did not work, Polk was counting on Mexican soldiers to fire the first shot. One month after American soldiers arrived at the Rio Grande, Mexican troops attacked a United States patrol party and killed eleven soldiers and captured fifty-two prisoners. Following the attack, Polk demanded that Congress declare war on Mexico. It did so on 13 May, 1846. The Mexican-American War lasted for two years, with the United States winning the war and gaining more than five-hundred thousand square miles of Northern Mexican Territories.
American political views regarding the Mexican-American War were divided. According to Encyclopedia Britannica, Democratic southern states approved the war (Mexican-American War). They had plans on extending slavery to the newly acquired land. The Whig Party viewed Polk's motives for the war "as conscienceless land grabbing." Many Whigs were against slavery, and they believed that the purpose of the war was to expand and increase slavery. Abolitionists were very much opposed to the war. Like most of the Whigs, they did not want slavery extended to the new territory. They had no doubt that if slavery was permitted in the newly acquired land, it would enhance the power of the existing southern slave states.
Henry David Thoreau, one of the many abolitionists opposed to the Mexican-American War, publicly shared his views about the war in an 1848 lecture titled "Civil Disobedience." One year later, the lecture was published. In "Civil Disobedience," Thoreau argues that an individual should follow their conscience and not support a government that he or she believes is unjust. Referring to the U.S. government's actions and role in the Mexican-American War, Thoreau writes, "the work of comparatively a few individuals using the standing government as their tool, for in the outset the people would not have consented to this measure" (305). Thoreau believes that the war was instigated by a few aggressive members of the U.S. government, and if it had consulted with the public, the U.S. would not have been involved in the war. It is obvious that Thoreau is referring to President Polk's determination to acquire Mexico's Northern Territories at all costs. This includes Polk's blatant action of placing American troops on the Rio Grande, knowing that it would most likely cause the Mexican government to order its troops to attack the American military. Polk went so far as to hope Mexico would attack first so that it would appear to the rest of the world as the aggressor

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 749
  1. First, please put this through https://www.grammarcheck.net/editor/ and see what results you get.

    Then make corrections.

    Then post your next draft, and someone here might check it for you.

    Two things I see right off the bat --
    ~ commas belong both before AND AFTER the year in a date (unless that date is at the end of a sentence).
    ~ make sure all verb tenses are consistent. Since you are writing about something in history, go through and make sure you're using past tenses, not switching back and forth between past and present.

  2. I am having difficulty finding your thesis (ie, point). Your last paragraph, if that is a concluding paragraph, seems to focus on Thoreau's objections and views on civil disobedience. Is that your thesis? If so, why are the points above even raised, they do not support the thesis.
    So basically, this seems to be a report, without a point. Surely you can do better at finding what you want to say, organizing it into supporting thoughts, and drawing a conclusion.

    Crafting is another thing I noticed, sometimes your word choice is not the best, as one example "Mexican-American War was a result of Manifest Destiny. ," It was not a result, it was a example of that type of thinking. In current times, it was very similar to the make America Great Again type of hype, that the US can do no wrong. That type of thinking can lead to dangerous things...thank God <note capital G> President Polk did not command nuclear weapons. Basically, what I am saying on crafting, you need after writing, to set it aside, and come back a day later and do your proofing.

  3. Bobpursley is right. You haven't supplied a thesis statement -- your point.

    Go here -- https://leo.stcloudstate.edu/acadwrite/thesistatement.html -- to learn how to write thesis statements. (Hint: The second example in each pair is a true thesis statement.)

  4. Thank you I will make these improvements

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0
  5. you spelled grande wrong

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Social Studies

    Hello! I have to write an essay for Social Studies. I wrote it, but it needs a ton of work. If anyone has some time, it would be greatly appreciated! I need some suggestions- And I know there are a ton. Thank you so so so so so so

    asked by CellLover727 on November 19, 2019
  2. History

    I'm writing an essay about the Mexican American war. Is there a link to a good website for it?? Thank you:)

    asked by Anonymous on January 25, 2017
  3. Social Studies

    I need information on the... Mexican government during the time of the Mexican-American war I also need information on the American Settlers during that same time (Mexican-American war)

    asked by EmberShy on October 14, 2016
  4. history

    While the United States referred to the conflict with Mexico as the Mexican War, Mexicans called the war the North American Invasion. What do these different names suggest about each country's perspective on the war? is it because

    asked by y912f on May 5, 2009
  5. Statistics

    In the case of Castaneda vs Partida, it was noted that although 80% of the population in a Texas county was Mexican-American, only 39% of those summoned for grand juries were Mexican-American. Assume that 12 jurors are to be

    asked by tamar on November 17, 2017
  1. Social studies

    Which of the following best describes a way in which the United states had helped the Mexican economy to grow? Allowing Mexican workers in the United states to send remittance home. Signing NAFTA to encourage free trade. (MY

    asked by LOVE on February 1, 2016
  2. Social studies

    Which of the following doubled the size of the United States in 1803? A. the Civil War B. the Louisiana Purchase C. the American Revolution D. the Mexican-American War

    asked by coolkid375 on February 19, 2020
  3. Cultural Diversity

    Can someone please help with this question on my assignment? A culture's emphasis on autonomy or dependence impacts adult-child interaction. Of the following choices, the ____________cultures are most closely aligned in valuing

    asked by Rose on October 30, 2007
  4. social studies

    the mexican-american war added the mexican cession to the U.S. in 1846-1848. what effect did this have on sectionalism in america?

    asked by dsd on October 27, 2010
  5. help

    can anyone answer this...if you want me to try first i came up with the answer A. for the following question Which of the following best describes a way in which the United States has helped the Mexican economy to grow? A.allowing

    asked by dalia on March 4, 2014
  6. statistics

    In the case of Castaneda vs Partida, it was noted that although 80% of the population in a Texas county was Mexican-American, only 39% of those summoned for grand juries were Mexican-American. Assume that 12 jurors are to be

    asked by Linda Joy on November 21, 2017

More Similar Questions