Category Two: Composition and Content of each Address (50 marks)
Speech 1: Dananjaya Hettiarachchi (i see something)
Speech 2: Mohammed Qahtani
-Claims or contentions
In Speech 1 by Dananjaya Hettiarachchi, the claims or contentions presented are not clearly mentioned in the prompt. However, based on the title "I see something," it can be assumed that the speaker might discuss the power of observation and perception and how it can contribute to personal growth and success. The speech might involve highlighting instances where keen observation has led to identifying opportunities or understanding people's behavior.
In Speech 2 by Mohammed Qahtani, the claims or contentions are not explicitly provided in the prompt. However, based on Qahtani's reputation as the winner of the World Championship of Public Speaking, it can be assumed that his speech would involve a persuasive argument or a captivating story to convey a message. He may present claims related to the importance of effective communication, building connections with the audience, or the ability to inspire and motivate others through public speaking.
Speech 1: Dananjaya Hettiarachchi:
- Claims or contentions: The main claim or contention of Dananjaya Hettiarachchi's speech is that he sees something - something that is not visible to others. He introduces this claim at the beginning of his speech and uses it as a central theme throughout his presentation. He suggests that he has the ability to perceive things that are hidden or overlooked by others, and he explores the significance of this unique perspective.
Speech 2: Mohammed Qahtani:
- Claims or contentions: The specific claims or contentions of Mohammed Qahtani's speech are not mentioned in the given information. More details or the actual content of the speech are required to provide a detailed answer.
Claims or contentions are the main arguments or points that a speaker makes during their speech. They are the statements or ideas that they present to support their overall message or persuade the audience to agree with their viewpoint.
To evaluate the claims or contentions in Speech 1 by Dananjaya Hettiarachchi and Speech 2 by Mohammed Qahtani, you can follow these steps:
1. Listen or read the speeches: Start by listening to or reading the speeches carefully, paying close attention to the main arguments or points made by each speaker.
2. Identify the claims: As you go through the speeches, look for statements that express a strong belief or position. These claims will usually be central to the speaker's message and may be explicitly stated or implied.
3. Analyze the evidence: Once you have identified the claims, examine the evidence or supporting information provided by each speaker to back up their claims. Look for concrete examples, statistics, research findings, personal experiences, or logical reasoning that supports their arguments.
4. Consider counterarguments: Think about any potential counterarguments or opposing viewpoints that could challenge the validity of the claims made by each speaker. Are there any gaps in their reasoning or evidence?
5. Evaluate the strength of the claims: Assess the strength of the claims by considering the quality and relevance of the evidence provided. Determine if the claims are logical, well-supported, and convincing to the audience.
6. Compare the speeches: Lastly, compare the claims and their supporting contentions in both speeches. Analyze the effectiveness of each speaker's arguments in terms of clarity, persuasion, and overall impact.
By following these steps, you can assess and evaluate the claims and contentions in Speech 1 by Dananjaya Hettiarachchi and Speech 2 by Mohammed Qahtani, and form your own judgment about the composition and content of each address.