make a Text Dependent Literary Analysis Portfolio
in the swallow and the pumpkin seed
retold by Elisa Oh
Think about how the brothers’ values are different. Make notes!
Think about how these values affect their actions, which affect the outcome of the story. Make notes!
Decide what lesson is being taught in the folk tale. How does this lesson help you identify a theme?
In "The Swallow and the Pumpkin Seed" retold by Elisa Oh, the brothers' values are clearly depicted as different. The older brother values hard work, perseverance, and patience, as seen in his decision to plant and tend to the pumpkin seed despite his initial skepticism. On the other hand, the younger brother values impulsiveness, quick fixes, and shortcuts, as shown by his choice to try and force the seed to grow with magic.
These differing values greatly affect the brothers' actions and ultimately determine the outcome of the story. The older brother's dedication to nurturing the seed with care and diligence leads to a bountiful harvest of pumpkins, while the younger brother's impulsive magic spells only serve to hinder the growth of the seed.
The lesson taught in this folk tale is that hard work, patience, and perseverance are ultimately rewarded, while shortcuts and quick fixes often lead to failure. This lesson helps identify a theme of the importance of taking the time to cultivate and nurture relationships, goals, or dreams in order to achieve success in the long run.
Overall, the values and actions of the brothers in "The Swallow and the Pumpkin Seed" highlight the importance of hard work and dedication in achieving one's goals, and the consequences of seeking shortcuts or easy solutions. This text dependent literary analysis portfolio serves to deepen our understanding of the story's themes and messages.