[1 Point] (Question 5): Use the excerpt to answer the question. "What is a power, but the ability or faculty of doing a thing? What is the ability to do a thing, but the power of employing the MEANS necessary to its execution? What is a ;legislative power, but a power of making laws? What the MEANS to execute a legislative power but LAWS? What is the power playing and collecting taxes, but a legislative power, or a power of making laws to lay and collect taxes? What the proper means of executing such a power, but necessary and proper laws?" Which is BEST Summarizes this quote from the Federalist, no. 33?
Answer 1A: The elastic clause would not create tyrannical government, but enable the government to perform basic functions crucial for it effectiveness.
Answer 2B: Allowing for implied powers by adding the elastic clause could potentially take power away from the from executive branch.
Answer 3C: The elastic clause would create a tyrannical government and should not be part of the Constitution.
Answer 4D: Expressed powers are necessary for a government to function because Congress needs a certain amount of power.
Answer 1A: The elastic clause would not create tyrannical government, but enable the government to perform basic functions crucial for its effectiveness.
Answer 1A: The elastic clause would not create a tyrannical government, but enable the government to perform basic functions crucial for its effectiveness.
To answer this question, we need to analyze the given excerpt from the Federalist, no. 33. The author discusses the concept of power and its relation to the ability to do something. They explain that a power is merely the ability or faculty to do a thing, and the ability to do something is the power of employing the means necessary for its execution. The author further illustrates that legislative power is the power of making laws, and the means necessary to execute legislative power are laws themselves.
Based on this analysis, we can conclude that the main idea conveyed in the excerpt is that legislative power is essential for making laws and executing them, and the means necessary for executing this power are the necessary and proper laws. Therefore, the best summary of this quote is:
Answer 4D: Expressed powers are necessary for a government to function because Congress needs a certain amount of power.
This answer accurately captures the concept of legislative power and the means necessary for its execution as explained in the excerpt.