What Scientific evidence do the scientists have to support their claim?
( Two teens find an extract from common seeds can kill mosquito larvae and may also repel biting adult insects.)
Information not given.
To determine the scientific evidence supporting the claim that an extract from common seeds can kill mosquito larvae and repel biting adult insects, scientists often conduct experiments and studies. Here are the typical steps scientists might take to gather evidence:
1. Observational studies: Scientists may observe the behavior of mosquito larvae and adult mosquitoes in the presence of the seed extract. They might record whether the larvae die after exposure to the extract and whether adult mosquitoes avoid areas treated with the extract.
2. Laboratory experiments: In a controlled laboratory setting, scientists may expose mosquito larvae to various concentrations of the seed extract. They can observe the mortality rate of the larvae at different concentrations, allowing them to determine the effectiveness of the extract in killing the larvae.
3. Field studies: Scientists may conduct experiments in outdoor settings where there are natural populations of mosquitoes. They can apply the seed extract to certain areas while leaving others untreated. By comparing mosquito populations in treated and untreated areas, scientists can assess the extract's ability to repel adult mosquitoes and reduce their numbers.
4. Chemical analysis: The seed extract can be chemically analyzed to identify any active compounds present. Scientists can determine whether these compounds have known insecticidal or repellent properties and verify their presence in the extract.
5. Peer-reviewed studies: The findings from these experiments and studies are typically published in scientific journals after undergoing a rigorous peer-review process. This allows other experts in the field to evaluate the research methodology, results, and conclusions.
Scientific evidence is obtained through repeated experiments, consistent results, and independent verification. It is important to note that the evidence supporting the claim may vary depending on the specific research conducted and the scientific consensus within the field.
To support their claim that an extract from common seeds can kill mosquito larvae and repel adult insects, scientists would need to provide scientific evidence. Here's how scientists typically gather evidence in these types of studies:
1. Conducting experiments: Scientists would start by creating controlled experiments to test the effects of the seed extract on mosquito larvae. They would set up different groups, including a control group where larvae are not exposed to the extract, and other groups with varying concentrations of the extract. The scientists would measure the larvae's survival rate and compare it to the control group.
2. Analyzing data: After conducting the experiments, scientists would collect and analyze the data they gathered. They would compare the survival rates of the larvae exposed to the extract to those in the control group. If the larvae exposed to the extract had significantly lower survival rates, it would suggest that the extract is effective in killing mosquito larvae.
3. Replication: To verify their findings, scientists would need to replicate the experiments multiple times. This ensures that their results are consistent and not due to chance. If multiple trials consistently show that the extract kills mosquito larvae, it adds weight to the evidence supporting their claim.
4. Conducting further research: After obtaining initial positive results, scientists may investigate the mechanism of action of the seed extract, explore its safety, and test its effectiveness against adult mosquitoes. This would involve additional experiments and data analysis to support their claim of repelling biting adult insects.
Once scientists have conducted thorough experiments, analyzed the data, replicated the results, and conducted further research, they can present their findings in scientific journals or publications. This allows other scientists to review and scrutinize their work, contributing to scientific consensus on the capability of the seed extract to kill mosquito larvae and repel adult insects.