english-othello

It is quoted in Augustine's confessions, "the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life." if this is so, then I believe Ambrose is telling Augustine the the letter, or the law, or exact words in the bible aren't meant to be taken literally, but figuratively in order to obtain spiritual life and understand God.

How then is Iago teaching the opposite lesson to this then? to as you say, take things as they are stated?
what would specific examples be?

I'm so sorry but I'm just having trouble understanding

  1. 👍
  2. 👎
  3. 👁
  1. Not having read Othello, and not having read Augustine since 1979, I cannot comment about the works other than what you've quoted.

    My question for you is this: Are you taking this one quotation from Augustine as representative of the overall message in ALL his confessions?

    Here are some sites that may help:

    https://www.google.com/search?q=othello

    http://www.ipl.org/div/litcrit/bin/litcrit.out.pl?au=aug-314

    http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/basis/confessions-bod.html
    from https://www.google.com/search?q=augustine+confessions

    1. 👍
    2. 👎
    👤
    Writeacher
  2. Laura, that quote of Ambrose is really a quote from the Apostle Paul in the New Testament. In a general sense it means the spirit of the word is more important than the words used to describe them. Paul did not ever condone adding to the simple spirit of love God, and love one another. Gnostics and a few others of those times took Gods law and made Man law to follow, in convoluted meanings. Paul was saying ignore those secret meanings, stick with the basic meaning: Love God, love one another. Ambrose is the strawman Paul here, it is a literary trick Augustine used to get the basic truth out, without church censure. After all, who in the church can attack Paul's teaching....remember that Ambrose was a teacher who was not in widely held esteem in the church at that time (Later, he and Augustine were made saints).
    Ambrose is arguing against reading too much into words that describe God's word. The simple fact was God loved man, and forgave him his sins, and God commanded us to love God with all our heart, and love one another. Now, with the words in the Bible describing that love, wars are waged in God's name, killing is done in God's name, and basic indecency (starving populations, destruction, etc) is done in God's name. Ambrose is stating as Paul did: Those are not the meaning of God's word, it is a convoluted meaning taken from twisting words in the Bible and other texts. I hope this helps.

    1. 👍
    2. 👎
    👤
    bobpursley
  3. One last thought on this. Paul preached the Spirit of the law was love (Romans 13:10 et al). The meaning of the law was love. Jesus stated that clearly (Matt 22:47,40). Ambrose is saying the same thing Paul is saying, that the message of the law is simple, don't try to make more of it with convoluted words and logic. To me, Iago's lesson in Othello is a lesson in hate, deception, jealousy, and evil. Paul teaches these things are a result of twisting the law, and not following the spirit. The irony is Iago wanted to be known as the honest one, the one who spoke truth, that others should not go beyond what he said to be truth. So we have a comparison of Ambrose's teaching of Pauline principles, and Iago who demonstrated those same principles in his use of the letter of the word as causing evil. Paul (Ambrose) can easily now reflect.."I told you so", and Iago can reflect "It is not me who is evil, it is you".
    The truth is that the evil we see is as Augustine stated, in us all. Iago, and Ambrose see different ways it can be used. One for the good of man, the other the good for a particular man.
    You have a great assignment. Have fun with it.

    1. 👍
    2. 👎
    👤
    bobpursley

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. world issuse

    I'm a 7 letter word u read daily,my 5th 6th and 7th letter increase each year,my 3rd n 4th letter are the same,my 3rd 2nd n 5th letter cover 75% of the world.

  2. us history

    1. What was unusual about the people who made up the population of St. Augustine, Florida, in the early 1800s? A. Most people who settled in St. Augustine in the early 1800s were Cubans who were escaping from an autocratic

  3. Mathematics 6th grade

    You write each letter of the word MATHEMATICS on a piece of paper and place each letter in a bag. You select one letter at random. What is P(consonant) A:7/11 B:7/4 C: 4/11

  4. english ASAP

    which excerpt from the play best supports the answer to the previous question? a)"more than eighteen hundred... a tremendous family to provide for!" b)"these children are his? on his meager earning! what foolishness!" c) Do you

  1. english

    Solve this riddle :- my first letter is in chocolate but not in gram. My second letter is in cake and also in jam. My third letter in time table is easily found. My whole name is a friend who's often around. What am I?

  2. MATH - URGENT!!!

    In how many ways can you spell the word COOL in the grid below? You can start on any letter, then on each step you can step one letter in any direction (up, down, left, right, or diagonal). You cannot visit the same letter twice.

  3. Memorable Letter Evaluation (Writeacher)

    Write a letter to your parents about a memorable moment in your life, using imagery to capture your experience. I origionally sumbitted a different letter, but Bob insisted that I should write more about my feelings toward my

  4. english

    I am supposed to explain this quote from the Scarlet Letter: "To the untrue man, the whole universe is false, ---it is impalpable, --- it shrinks to nothing within his grasp." Can somebody give me some ideas on what this quote's

  1. ENGLISH

    1. Consider this quote: "In each of these historical instances . . . mistrust led to misunderstanding, which led to armed conflict." The ellipsis in this quote is appropriate if A. the omission is longer than 10 words. B. the

  2. Mechanical engineering

    The temperature of piece of copper of mass 250g is raised to 100% and is then transferred to well lagged aluminum can mass 10g containing 120g of methylated spirit at 10%. Calculate the final steady temperature after the spirit

  3. 8th grade Math

    Penelope created a game using a bag of 26 tiles, each with a different letter of the alphabet written on it. She uses a stopwatch to time how fast she can create one 5-letter word from a set of five randomly selected letters. To

  4. English

    In First Confessions, Nora can best be identified as? A:flat*** B:round C:dynamic D:protagonist

You can view more similar questions or ask a new question.