Write Comparative Paragraphs
Write three paragraphs that compare From Scratch and Amy’s Metaphor.
Write a paragraph that summarizes the stories and describes the similarities and differences in the plot structures of the stories.
Write a paragraph that compares the point of view and main characters of the stories.
Write a paragraph that explains which story you liked more based on the comparisons you made in this portfolio of the stories’ style, tone, plot structure, character development, or point of view.
From Scratch and Amy's Metaphor are both short stories that explore themes of self-discovery and personal growth. In From Scratch, the protagonist embarks on a journey of self-discovery through the process of baking bread from scratch, while in Amy's Metaphor, the main character uses a metaphorical device to navigate her own emotional journey. Both stories follow a similar structure in that they both focus on the internal struggles and growth of the main characters, but From Scratch is more straightforward in its plotline, while Amy's Metaphor takes a more abstract and metaphorical approach.
From Scratch is told from a first-person point of view, allowing readers to directly experience the protagonist's thoughts and emotions as she learns to bake bread. In contrast, Amy's Metaphor is told from a third-person omniscient point of view, giving readers a more detached perspective on the main character's emotional journey. The main characters in both stories are women who are seeking to understand themselves and their place in the world, but their methods of self-discovery differ. From Scratch focuses on the physical act of baking as a metaphor for personal growth, while Amy's Metaphor uses a more abstract and metaphorical device to explore the protagonist's emotional journey.
Overall, I found Amy's Metaphor to be a more engaging and thought-provoking story. The abstract and metaphorical approach to storytelling allowed for a deeper exploration of the main character's emotional journey and personal growth. While From Scratch was enjoyable in its simplicity and focus on the physical act of baking, I found Amy's Metaphor to be more compelling in its exploration of the complexities of human emotion and self-discovery. The unique narrative style and point of view in Amy's Metaphor added a depth and richness to the story that I found to be more impactful than the more straightforward approach of From Scratch.
make it like a 6th grader wrote it
From Scratch and Amy’s Metaphor are two stories about people figuring out who they are and growing as individuals. In From Scratch, the main character learns about herself while making bread. In Amy's Metaphor, the character goes on an emotional journey using metaphors. Both stories show how the characters change and grow, but From Scratch is more simple while Amy's Metaphor is more imaginative.
From Scratch is told from the main character's point of view, so we get to see her thoughts and feelings up close. Amy’s Metaphor is told from a different perspective, so we get to see the character from afar. Both stories have female main characters who are trying to understand themselves and their place in the world. From Scratch uses baking as a symbol of growth, while Amy’s Metaphor uses metaphors to explore emotions.
I liked Amy’s Metaphor more because it made me think about emotions and personal growth in a different way. The creative storytelling and unique point of view in Amy’s Metaphor drew me in more than the straightforward approach of From Scratch. While From Scratch was fun to read because it was simple, Amy’s Metaphor was more intriguing because of the way it explored the character’s feelings and growth.