group A: Extra long nails, 1 minute 3 seconds to collect candy, 8 minutes 12 seconds to eat candy

group B No digits; hands paddle-like, 15 seconds to collect candy, 7 minutes 18 seconds to eat candy

group C Normal, 22 seconds to collect candy, 2 minutes 44 seconds to eat candy

group D Hands fused in front of body; no range of motion, Did not collect 15 pieces.
Collected 11 pieces, Ate 11 pieces; 4 minutes 12 seconds to eat candy

group E Webbing on hands and feet 11 minutes 45 seconds to collect candy, 17 minutes 12 seconds to eat candy

group F No peripheral, 3 minutes 2 seconds to collect candy, 2 minutes 52 seconds to eat candy

group G Blind Did not collect 15 pieces, Collected 4 pieces in 4 minutes, Ate only 4 pieces; 1 minute 16 seconds to eat candy

group H Short legs; normal number of digits on hands and feet, 55 seconds to collect candy, 3 minutes 2 seconds to eat candy

The process of evolution involves changes in the genetic makeup of a population over a period of time. Sexual reproduction enhances variability among offspring. The random alteration of DNA from parent to offspring, called mutations, also produces variable characteristics in offspring. Some mutations can be helpful, while others can be harmful and hinder survival. In this experiment, students mimicked random mutations. Data was collected to determine if the mutations were helpful or harmful when trying to collect and eat food. Collection of 15 pieces of candy was ideal and needed for survival.

Consider the mutations to the appendages and digits. Which mutation would MOST LIKELY result in the extinction of that group of organisms?

A. Group A long nails
B. Group D hands fused
C. Group H short legs
D. Group B paddle hands

The mutation in group D, where the hands are fused in front of the body with no range of motion, would most likely result in the extinction of that group of organisms. This mutation severely hinders the ability to collect and eat food, as seen by the fact that they did not collect the required 15 pieces of candy. In a survival situation where food collection is vital, this mutation would greatly reduce the chances of survival for this group.