State whether management's intention to increase automation at the hospital is ethically right, ethically wrong, or a moral dilemma and explain your answer. Your answer should clearly identify the two competing values that management should take in consideration in their decision to further automate process at the hospital.
Management's intention to increase automation at the hospital can be considered a moral dilemma. On one hand, increasing automation can lead to increased efficiency, improved patient outcomes, and enhanced quality of care. This can ultimately benefit both patients and staff by lightening workloads and reducing the potential for errors.
On the other hand, increasing automation can also lead to job losses and potential displacement of staff. This raises ethical concerns about the well-being and livelihood of employees who may be negatively impacted by the automation process.
In this situation, management must weigh the benefits of automation in terms of improving patient care and efficiency against the potential negative impact on staff members who may be displaced. It is important for management to consider both the principle of beneficence (doing good for patients and improving healthcare outcomes) and the principle of non-maleficence (avoiding harm to staff members who may be negatively impacted by job losses). Ultimately, management must strive to find a balance that prioritizes patient care without disregarding the well-being of their employees.