1. Using a T-chart, identify the claims presented by pro-imperialists and anti-imperialists.
2. Using a two-column chart, write notes for a point-counterpoint debate in which you summarize the pro-imperialist points and anti-imperialist counterpoints in the argument over imperialism.
T-Chart:
Pro-Imperialists claims:
1. Imperialism leads to economic benefits for the dominant country, such as access to new markets and resources.
2. Imperialism helps spread civilization and modernization to less developed societies.
3. Imperialism strengthens the dominant country's military and political power on a global scale.
Anti-Imperialists claims:
1. Imperialism exploits and oppresses indigenous populations in colonized territories.
2. Imperialism undermines self-determination and sovereignty of colonized nations.
3. Imperialism perpetuates inequality and injustice on a global scale.
Two-Column Chart:
Pro-Imperialist Points:
1. Economic benefits: Imperialism expands markets and access to resources for the dominant country, leading to increased wealth and power.
2. Civilizing mission: Imperialism helps bring modernization, education, and technological advancements to less developed societies.
3. Strategic advantage: Imperialism strengthens the dominant country's military presence and political influence around the world.
Anti-Imperialist Counterpoints:
1. Exploitation and oppression: Imperialism exploits and harms indigenous populations, leading to economic exploitation and cultural destruction.
2. Violation of sovereignty: Imperialism undermines the rights of colonized nations to self-determination and autonomy.
3. Inequality and injustice: Imperialism perpetuates a system of domination and inequality, benefiting the powerful at the expense of the oppressed.