Write a compare and contrast analysis essay of how "Broken Chain" and "Fish Cheeks" both address a common theme about belonging.
In the short stories "Broken Chain" by Gary Soto and "Fish Cheeks" by Amy Tan, both authors address a common theme about belonging and identity. Though the two stories have different plots and settings, both explore the struggles of individuals trying to find acceptance and belonging within their respective cultures.
In "Broken Chain," the protagonist Alfonso faces feelings of inadequacy and insecurity as he compares himself to his more popular and athletic older brother Ernie. Alfonso's desire to impress a girl by fixing his broken bike chain symbolizes his need for acceptance and validation from others. However, despite his attempts to fit in and be like his brother, Alfonso ultimately learns the importance of embracing his own identity and strengths.
On the other hand, in "Fish Cheeks," the protagonist Amy struggles with her cultural identity and belonging while attending a Christmas dinner with her American crush and his family. Amy is embarrassed by her Chinese customs and traditions, feeling like an outsider in a predominantly white and American setting. However, by the end of the story, Amy realizes the importance of embracing her cultural heritage and finds a sense of pride in her identity.
Both stories highlight the challenges of navigating one's sense of belonging within different cultural contexts. While Alfonso grapples with fitting in with his peers and living up to societal expectations, Amy faces the pressure to conform to American ideals of beauty and acceptability. Ultimately, both protagonists come to the realization that true belonging comes from accepting oneself and being proud of one's heritage.
Furthermore, both "Broken Chain" and "Fish Cheeks" emphasize the importance of embracing one's cultural background and identity in order to find a sense of belonging. Alfonso learns to appreciate his own strengths and individuality, while Amy comes to accept and celebrate her Chinese heritage. Both stories serve as a reminder that true belonging is not about conforming to societal norms or fitting in with others, but about embracing one's uniqueness and cultural heritage.
In conclusion, "Broken Chain" and "Fish Cheeks" both address the theme of belonging and identity through the struggles and growth of their respective protagonists. While Alfonso and Amy face different challenges in finding acceptance within their cultures, both stories ultimately convey the message that true belonging comes from embracing one's identity and heritage.