Based on the student data, was the scientists' statement correct? Explain.

Question

Based on the student data, was the scientists' statement correct? Explain.

Responses
A Yes. It is particle size that determines the growth rate of the plants.Yes. It is particle size that determines the growth rate of the plants.
B Yes. Student data was inconclusive because they only grew three plants.Yes. Student data was inconclusive because they only grew three plants.
C No. Student observations determined that plants grew best in the sandy soil.No. Student observations determined that plants grew best in the sandy soil.
D No. Student observations noted differences in growth for the three soil types.

Answer 1

The scientists' statement was not entirely correct based on the student data. While particle size may play a role in the growth rate of plants, the student observations showed that plants grew best in sandy soil, which indicates that other factors besides particle size may also be influencing plant growth. Additionally, the student observations noted differences in growth for the three soil types, which suggests that there are variables other than just particle size at play. Therefore, it is not accurate to solely attribute plant growth rate to particle size based on the student data.