Respond to these questions. Cite evidence from the text to support your positions. Then, respond to two of your peers’ posts by summarizing the points on which you agree and disagree.
N. Scott Momaday connects his personal history with that of the Kiowa tribe, indicating that both personal and cultural experience have a role in forming his identity.
How does the culture of the Kiowa tribe affect Momaday’s personal identity? Use textual evidence to support your answer.
What other examples (in literature or life) can you think of in which personal and cultural identity are intertwined?
In "The Way to Rainy Mountain," N. Scott Momaday explores his personal connection to the Kiowa tribe and how their culture shapes his identity. He describes the Kiowa as a deeply spiritual people, with their own traditions, beliefs, and way of life. These cultural aspects are integral to Momaday's personal identity. For instance, he recounts a moment when he was given the Kiowa name "Tsoai," which means "rock." This name connects him to the natural world and the strength and resilience of the Kiowa people. He also speaks of the importance of storytelling in their culture, highlighting the role of oral tradition in shaping his own understanding of his heritage.
Another example of the intertwining of personal and cultural identity can be found in the novel "The Joy Luck Club" by Amy Tan. The book explores the experiences of four Chinese immigrant women and their American-born daughters. Through the narrative, the characters grapple with their Chinese cultural heritage and their American identities. The personal stories and experiences of each character are deeply influenced by their Chinese background and traditions, ultimately shaping who they are and how they navigate their lives.
In another literary example, in "Becoming" by Michelle Obama, the former First Lady reflects on her personal journey and the influence of her African-American heritage on her identity. She recounts the importance of her upbringing and the values instilled in her by her family and community. These cultural experiences and influences play a significant role in shaping her personal identity and her understanding of her place in the world.
Overall, the connection between personal and cultural identity is a common theme in literature and life. Our experiences, traditions, and beliefs shape who we are as individuals, and these are often deeply rooted in our cultural backgrounds.
I agree with my peer's points on how N. Scott Momaday's personal identity is shaped by the culture of the Kiowa tribe. The textual evidence provided supports this argument, as Momaday discusses his Kiowa name and the importance of storytelling in their culture. These elements highlight the interconnection between his personal experiences and his cultural heritage.
I also agree with the example provided by my peer of "The Joy Luck Club" by Amy Tan. The novel delves into the complex relationship between personal and cultural identities, showcasing the impact of Chinese heritage on the characters' lives and experiences.
However, I disagree with the second example provided by my peer, "Becoming" by Michelle Obama. While Michelle Obama acknowledges the influence of her African-American heritage, the book primarily focuses on her personal journey rather than explicitly exploring the connection between personal and cultural identity. Although cultural background plays a part in shaping her experiences, it is not as central to the narrative as it is in the other examples mentioned.