Select one of the prompts below and follow the directions. Your essay should be three paragraphs and must have a thesis statement in the first paragraph. Be sure to develop your ideas fully and to refer to the passage read in the section.
Some critics complain that contemporary fiction lacks moral standards and depicts a gloomy vision of an amoral society. Do you agree or disagree with these critics? Use the fiction in this unit to support your position.
"About Russell" by Rita Williams-Garcia:
"I Want to Be Miss America" by Julia Alvarez
I disagree with the critics who complain that contemporary fiction lacks moral standards and depicts a gloomy vision of an amoral society. The fiction in this unit provides ample evidence that contemporary fiction not only explores moral issues but also offers insightful commentary on society. In "About Russell" by Rita Williams-Garcia, the protagonist's journey towards self-acceptance and forgiveness highlights the importance of compassion and understanding. Similarly, in "I Want to Be Miss America" by Julia Alvarez, the narrator's struggle to navigate cultural expectations and find her own identity illustrates the complexities of morality and the impact of societal pressures.
In "About Russell," the protagonist, Adele, learns the value of empathy and forgiveness through her friendship with Russell. Despite initial reservations and prejudices, Adele eventually comes to understand and accept Russell for who he is, despite his differences. This journey of acceptance and growth showcases the moral themes of compassion and understanding. By depicting the protagonist's transformation, the story reminds readers of the importance of looking beyond surface judgments and embracing others with empathy.
"I Want to Be Miss America" also explores moral themes through the narrator's struggle to navigate cultural expectations. The narrator grapples with the pressure to conform to societal norms and ideals, ultimately realizing that true happiness lies in embracing her own identity. This story raises important questions about the impact of societal pressures and the moral choices individuals must make in order to find inner fulfillment. By challenging societal expectations and advocating for personal authenticity, the story encourages readers to reflect on their own moral values and choices.
In conclusion, the fiction in this unit demonstrates that contemporary fiction does not lack moral standards and does not solely depict a gloomy vision of an amoral society. Instead, these stories provide thought-provoking insights into moral issues and societal pressures. Through the journeys of the protagonists in "About Russell" and "I Want to Be Miss America," readers are reminded of the importance of compassion, understanding, and personal authenticity. These stories serve as powerful reminders that contemporary fiction has the ability to explore and challenge moral standards in ways that are both engaging and relevant.