Why doesn’t Elie follow the advice? in the book night
Elie, the protagonist in the book Night, does not always follow the advice given due to various reasons:
1. Loss of faith: Elie struggles with his faith throughout the book, especially after witnessing the atrocities of the Holocaust. As his belief in a benevolent God diminishes, he becomes more skeptical of the advice given by those who still hold onto their faith.
2. Survival instinct: In the brutal and dehumanizing conditions of the concentration camps, Elie often has to make decisions solely based on his survival instinct. Sometimes, following the advice given may not align with his personal instincts or judgment.
3. Lack of trust: Elie's experiences in the concentration camps have eroded his trust in others, including fellow prisoners and even some of the advice-givers. He becomes skeptical of the intentions behind the advice and may choose not to follow it as a result.
4. Desensitization: Over time, Elie becomes desensitized to the suffering around him. This desensitization can make him numb to the advice or guidance offered by others, as he views it as inconsequential in the face of the immense horrors he witnesses.
In the face of extreme circumstances and the dehumanizing environment of the Holocaust, Elie's actions often deviate from the advice given to him as he grapples with his faith, instincts, trust, and the numbing effect of his surroundings.