There is a new student at school. Jamie's friends are being rude, and she asks them to stop. Jamie's friends say that it seems like Jamie likes the new student more than the friends she's known since kindergarten. Which logical fallacy have Jamie's friends used?

Bandwagon
False analogy
Hasty generalization
Straw man

The logical fallacy used by Jamie's friends is a straw man fallacy. They are misrepresenting Jamie's argument and exaggerating it to make it easier to attack.