Use the scenario to answer the question.
Two students in the debate club are preparing arguments for and against the use of nuclear energy. Each student will have five minutes to present an argument based on scientific evidence.
The student who supports the use of nuclear energy is considered a proponent of nuclear energy.
The student who does not support the use of nuclear energy is considered an opponent of nuclear energy.
The proponent presents his argument first. His argument is based on the following key points. Nuclear energy does not emit any greenhouse gases.
Nuclear energy does not contribute to global warming.
Next, the opponent presents his argument.
Which pair of key points is the opponent most likely to use in his argument against the use of nuclear energy?
Nuclear energy is not a renewable resource.
Nuclear energy releases gases into the atmosphere that deplete the ozone layer.
Nuclear energy contaminates local water supplies.
Nuclear energy impacts climate change.
There is no safe place or method to store nuclear waste.
Nuclear energy creates waste that remains dangerously radioactive for thousands of years.
Nuclear energy creates acid fog and clouds.
Nuclear waste in the air harms trees.
The opponent is most likely to use the pair of key points:
- Nuclear energy is not a renewable resource.
- Nuclear energy releases gases into the atmosphere that deplete the ozone layer.
The opponent is most likely to use the following pair of key points in his argument against the use of nuclear energy:
1. Nuclear energy is not a renewable resource.
2. Nuclear energy releases gases into the atmosphere that deplete the ozone layer.
The opponent is most likely to use the following pair of key points in his argument against the use of nuclear energy:
- Nuclear energy is not a renewable resource: This argument suggests that nuclear energy relies on finite resources such as uranium, which will eventually run out. It implies that investing in renewable energy sources that are sustainable in the long term, such as solar or wind power, may be a better option.
- Nuclear energy releases gases into the atmosphere that deplete the ozone layer: This argument suggests that nuclear energy may contribute to environmental harm by releasing gases that can deplete the ozone layer. It implies that using nuclear energy can have negative consequences for the environment and human health.
These points focus on the sustainability of nuclear energy and potential negative impacts on the environment, which are commonly used arguments against the use of nuclear energy.