How is a dictatorship SIMILAR to an absolute monarchy? Who makes the decisions in each government?
A dictatorship and an absolute monarchy share certain similarities in terms of power concentration and decision-making. In both forms of government, ultimate authority rests in the hands of a single individual.
1. Concentration of power: Both a dictatorship and an absolute monarchy involve a concentration of power in the hands of one individual. This person possesses substantial authority and control over various aspects of governance, including making laws, implementing policies, and enforcing them.
2. Decision-making authority: In both forms of government, the leader has the absolute power to make decisions. They can establish laws, issue decrees, and enforce policies without the need for democratic processes or consultation with other branches of government.
3. Lack of checks and balances: Dictatorships and absolute monarchies often lack effective checks and balances on the power of the ruler. Unlike democratic systems that distribute power among different branches of government, these forms of government give significant autonomy to the leader, reducing accountability and oversight.
However, it is important to note that there are some differences between a dictatorship and an absolute monarchy. Dictatorships generally come to power through force or military coup, while monarchies typically involve hereditary succession. Furthermore, in some absolute monarchies, the ruler's power might be limited by constitutional norms or the influence of other power centers, whereas dictatorships tend to rely solely on the will of the dictator.
A dictatorship and an absolute monarchy both have similarities in terms of concentrated power and decision-making authority. Here's a step-by-step breakdown of their similarities:
1. Concentration of Power: Both systems involve a concentration of power in the hands of a single ruler or a small group of individuals. In a dictatorship, power is typically held by a single dictator who exercises absolute control over the government, while in an absolute monarchy, power rests with a hereditary monarch who possesses unlimited authority.
2. Lack of Checks and Balances: In both systems, there is usually little to no separation of powers or checks and balances. The ruler in both a dictatorship and an absolute monarchy has significant control over the legislative, executive, and judicial branches, allowing them to make decisions without much opposition or constraints.
3. Personal Rule: Decisions in both types of government are often made by the ruler or monarch without significant input or consultation from other branches, advisors, or the general population. The ruler's decisions and policies hold significant weight and are typically implemented without opposition or debate.
Despite these similarities, there are also notable differences between the two forms of government:
1. Legitimacy: Absolute monarchies often claim their power is based on divine right or inherited authority, linking their rule to a long-standing tradition. Dictators, on the other hand, usually claim power through force, such as military coups or revolutions.
2. Succession: In absolute monarchies, power is passed down through hereditary lines, with the monarch's children or relatives inheriting the throne. In a dictatorship, succession is often determined by the current dictator, who may designate a successor or maintain power indefinitely.
3. Duration: Absolute monarchies historically have a tendency to last longer, as power transitions from one generation to the next within the same ruling family. Dictatorships, on the other hand, can vary in terms of duration, with some lasting for years while others are overthrown relatively quickly.
In summary, both a dictatorship and an absolute monarchy involve concentrated power and decision-making authority. The ruler or monarch holds significant control without strong checks and balances. However, absolute monarchies derive legitimacy from tradition or divine right, while dictators often seize power through force.
A dictatorship and an absolute monarchy are similar in that both forms of government concentrate power in the hands of one ruler. However, there are some differences in the decision-making process.
In a dictatorship, a single individual, known as the dictator, holds all the power. This person often acquires power through force or other means and exercises authority without any legal limitations. The dictator makes decisions without the input or consent of the general population. They have absolute control over government policies, laws, and regulations.
On the other hand, in an absolute monarchy, the decision-making power is also concentrated in the hands of a single ruler, usually a king or queen. However, the source of authority in an absolute monarchy is usually hereditary, meaning it is passed down through generations within a specific royal family. The monarch has final say in making decisions, although they may be advised by a council or other officials. The general population typically has limited or no participation in the decision-making process.
To summarize, in both dictatorship and absolute monarchy, decisions are made by a single ruler who holds significant power. However, in a dictatorship, the ruler often seizes power by force, while in an absolute monarchy, power is passed down through hereditary means.