LANG ARTS: DEVELOPING A TOPIC; Unit 5 Lesson 5
Which of the following situations provides the best elaboration for the topics discussed?
A. Elena is recommending that her friends take a class in auto repair. To elaborate, she might explain, "You never know when you're going to break down in the middle of nowhere."
B. Mingzhu is planning an opinion piece about the benefits of later start times at her school. To elaborate, she wants to include her opinion of when school should start.
C. Jackson is explaining why he admires a particular baseball player. To elaborate he could add a quotation from his dad about his own favorite baseball player.
D. Riley wants to tell older teenagers why young people need to vote. To elaborate, she could include facts that show how many younger people are registered to vote in the upcoming election.
The best elaboration for the topics discussed is option D. Riley wants to tell older teenagers why young people need to vote. To elaborate, she could include facts that show how many younger people are registered to vote in the upcoming election. Adding these facts would provide concrete evidence and support for Riley's argument and help to strengthen her point.
The situation that provides the best elaboration for the topics discussed is A. Elena is recommending that her friends take a class in auto repair. To elaborate, she might explain, "You never know when you're going to break down in the middle of nowhere." This elaboration explains the importance of taking a class in auto repair by highlighting a specific scenario where knowledge of auto repair could be very beneficial.
To determine which situation provides the best elaboration for the topics discussed, we need to carefully consider the given options and assess which one offers the most relevant and informative details.
A. In this situation, Elena is recommending her friends to take a class in auto repair. The provided elaboration, "You never know when you're going to break down in the middle of nowhere," adds a realistic scenario that highlights the importance of acquiring auto repair skills. This elaboration effectively supports Elena's recommendation by explaining the potential practical benefits of taking such a class.
B. Mingzhu is planning an opinion piece about the benefits of later start times at her school. The potential elaboration mentioned is including her opinion of when school should start. While this detail does contribute to the topic discussion, it focuses more on Mingzhu's personal perspective rather than offering broader information or evidence related to the benefits of later start times.
C. Jackson is explaining why he admires a particular baseball player. The suggested elaboration involves adding a quotation from his dad about his own favorite baseball player. While this detail does provide a personal touch, it does not significantly contribute to the discussion of why Jackson admires the mentioned player.
D. Riley wants to inform older teenagers about the importance of young people voting. The proposed elaboration suggests including facts about the number of younger people registered to vote in the upcoming election. This detail effectively supports the topic by providing statistical evidence that demonstrates the involvement of young people in the voting process.
Considering the aforementioned evaluation, option D seems to provide the best elaboration for the topic discussed as it offers concrete facts that directly support Riley's goal of informing older teenagers about the importance of young people voting.