A minimum of five justice votes must be included for what type of opinion to be issued?
dissenting opinion
concurrent opinion
majority opinion
per curiam opinion
A minimum of five justice votes must be included for a majority opinion to be issued.
A minimum of five justice votes must be included for a majority opinion to be issued.
A minimum of five justice votes must be included for a majority opinion to be issued in the context of the US Supreme Court.
To understand this, it is important to note how the decision-making process works within the Supreme Court. When the Court hears a case, the justices review the arguments and the relevant legal principles. After that, they engage in discussions and debates about the case. Each justice has the opportunity to express their views and opinions.
When the justices reach a decision on a case, the outcome can be reflected in various types of opinions. The most significant and authoritative one is the majority opinion. It represents the opinion of the Court and explains the reasoning behind the decision. In order for a majority opinion to be issued, it must have the support of at least five justices.
A dissenting opinion, on the other hand, is written by a justice or justices who disagree with the majority's decision. It outlines their different views and reasoning. A concurrent opinion is a separate opinion written by a justice who agrees with the majority's decision but for different reasons. Finally, a per curiam opinion is a decision issued "by the court" as a whole, without identifying which individual justices supported it. These opinions are typically brief and straightforward.
In summary, a minimum of five justice votes is required for a majority opinion to be issued, which makes it the most influential opinion in the US Supreme Court.