What message does the novel want to get across to us as readers by revealing how Arnold reflects on the fact that the Welpinit team is actually the underdogs and the Reardan team is the Goliaths?

Question

What message does the novel want to get across to us as readers by revealing how Arnold reflects on the fact that the Welpinit team is actually the underdogs and the Reardan team is the Goliaths?

Answer 1

The novel, "The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian" by Sherman Alexie, uses the revelation of Arnold's reflection to convey the message of challenging societal stereotypes and breaking free from the limitations imposed by one's identity and background.

By portraying the Welpinit team as underdogs and the Reardan team as Goliaths, the novel subverts common expectations and encourages readers to question preconceived notions. This reflection highlights the unfairness and ingrained prejudices that exist within society, particularly in relation to marginalized communities. It emphasizes how these stereotypes can hinder individuals and perpetuate a cycle of inequality.

The novel ultimately suggests that individuals have the power to redefine themselves and rise above the limitations imposed by societal expectations. Arnold's decision to play for Reardan and challenge the status quo reveals his resilience, determination, and refusal to be defined solely by his impoverished Native American background. Through this reflection, the novel urges readers to challenge the labels and expectations imposed on them and pursue their own dreams and aspirations, no matter the hardships they face or the odds against them.

Answer 2

The message that the novel, "The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian" by Sherman Alexie, wants to convey to readers through Arnold reflecting on the fact that the Welpinit team is the underdog and the Reardan team is the Goliath is that appearances can be deceiving and that stereotypes can be shattered when we challenge societal expectations and overcome adversity. By highlighting that the Welpinit team, representing Arnold's Native American community, is perceived as the underdog against the more privileged Reardan team, which represents a predominantly white and affluent school, the novel explores the themes of identity, resilience, and breaking down barriers. Arnold's realization highlights the stereotype that Native American people are expected to fail or not be as successful as others, and by defying these expectations, he challenges the notion that one's background or circumstances should determine their worth or capabilities. The novel ultimately encourages readers to challenge stereotypes, embrace their individuality, and strive for personal growth despite the obstacles they may face.