Please help! I'm reposting because nobody answered, so I'd be very appreciative if you could! Please, thanks!
From the sentence, "The South demanded that the people of the states involved settle the question," What was the position of the majority of the slave owners?
A. They demanded that slavery be made legal of the united states, or they would secede.
B. They condemned slavery as immoral but wanted to keep their own slaves.
C. They thought each state should decide for itself whether or not it should be a free state
D. They asked that the Supreme Court Settle the matter once and for all.
You probably got no reply because you haven't indicated what YOU think the correct response is.
Which of the four choices comes closest to the meaning/implication in this sentence?
"The South demanded that the people of the states involved settle the question."
Let us know.
I'm thinking maybe D?
To determine the position of the majority of the slave owners based on the given sentence, we need to analyze the sentence and infer the possible viewpoint.
In the sentence, it states, "The South demanded that the people of the states involved settle the question." From this, we can infer that the South, which included many slave-owning states, wanted the people of the states involved to decide on a certain matter.
Considering the given options:
A. "They demanded that slavery be made legal in the United States, or they would secede." This statement suggests that the majority of slave owners wanted to ensure the legality of slavery in the entire United States, or else they would secede. However, the given sentence does not directly support this option, as it does not specify the demand for the legality of slavery.
B. "They condemned slavery as immoral but wanted to keep their own slaves." This statement suggests that the majority of slave owners acknowledged the immorality of slavery but still wanted to maintain ownership of their slaves. The given sentence does not provide information regarding the moral stance of the slave owners, so this option cannot be confirmed.
C. "They thought each state should decide for itself whether or not it should be a free state." This statement suggests that the majority of slave owners believed in the concept of states' rights, where each state should have the power to determine its own stance on slavery. This aligns with the given sentence, which emphasizes the idea of the people in the states involved settling the question. Therefore, option C seems to be the most reasonable choice based on the given information.
D. "They asked that the Supreme Court settle the matter once and for all." This statement suggests that the majority of slave owners wanted the Supreme Court to make a final decision on the matter. The given sentence does not mention any involvement or request of the Supreme Court, so this option cannot be determined as the correct choice.
Based on the reasoning explained above, the position of the majority of slave owners, as inferred from the given sentence, is likely option C: "They thought each state should decide for itself whether or not it should be a free state."