This was originally posted on another student's thread.
5. How can you demonstrate the differences in the perspectives about Texas and its independence with historically accurate facts?
my answer:
Texas Declaration of Independence was drafted 1836. It was presided by 59 delegates aiming to outline a plan for a new republic.
does that sound right???
"It was presided by ... "
This doesn't make sense. What is "It"?
Yes, your answer is partially correct. The Texas Declaration of Independence was indeed drafted in 1836, and it was presided over by 59 delegates who aimed to outline a plan for a new republic. This document serves as a historically accurate fact that demonstrates the perspective of those who supported Texas' independence from Mexico during that time.
However, to fully demonstrate the differences in perspectives about Texas and its independence, it's important to consider other historically accurate facts as well. Here are a few additional examples:
1. Support for Independence: During the Texas Revolution, there were individuals and groups who supported Texas' independence from Mexico. These supporters believed that Texas should be an independent republic, free from Mexican rule.
2. Opposition to Independence: On the other hand, there were also individuals and groups who opposed Texas' independence. They believed in maintaining Texas as a part of Mexico and did not see a need for a separate republic.
3. The Alamo: The Battle of the Alamo, which took place in 1836, is a significant event that reflects different perspectives about Texas' independence. The defenders of the Alamo, such as William B. Travis and Davy Crockett, fought to defend Texas' independence from Mexican forces. On the other side, the Mexican army, led by General Antonio López de Santa Anna, believed in subduing the rebellion and maintaining control over Texas.
4. Annexation by the United States: After gaining independence from Mexico, Texas sought annexation by the United States. Some Texans saw annexation as a way to ensure security and stability for their newly formed republic. However, there were also those who opposed annexation, preferring to maintain independence rather than becoming part of the United States.
By considering these facts and others, you can demonstrate the differing perspectives about Texas and its independence, providing a more comprehensive understanding of the topic.
Yes, your answer is partially correct. The Texas Declaration of Independence was indeed drafted in 1836, and it was presided over by 59 delegates who sought to create a plan for a new republic. This demonstrates one perspective regarding Texas and its quest for independence. However, to fully demonstrate the differences in perspectives about Texas and its independence, it is important to include more historically accurate facts.
To further highlight the differing perspectives, you can consider including the following facts:
1. Mexican Perspective: Mexico viewed Texas as a rebellious territory that was still under Mexican rule. They believed that Texas was rightfully a part of Mexico, and therefore rejected any notions of Texas independence.
2. Anglo-American Perspective: Many Anglo-American settlers in Texas wanted independence from Mexico due to factors such as cultural differences, economic policies, and disputes over local autonomy. They argued that Texas should be independent, similar to the United States' fight for independence from Britain.
3. Native American Perspective: Various Native American tribes, including the Comanche and Kiowa, had already established longstanding presence in the region prior to Anglo-American and Mexican settlement. They had their own complex relationships and interactions with both the Mexican government and the Anglo-American settlers, which influenced their perspectives on Texas independence.
By incorporating these additional perspectives, you can provide a more comprehensive and historically accurate understanding of the differences in perspectives about Texas and its independence.