Hello, I have a question regarding 12 Angry Men and To Kill a Mockingbird. I have to compare and contrast Juror 8 to Atticus Finch. I can’t seem to find any differences, though. Does anyone know of any differences between these two men? Thanks!
Certainly! While both Juror 8 from 12 Angry Men and Atticus Finch from To Kill a Mockingbird share some similarities in their dedication to justice and their ability to challenge the wrongdoing, there are indeed some differences between these two characters. Here are a few points to consider:
1. Background and Profession: Juror 8 is an unnamed character who works as an architect, while Atticus Finch is a well-known lawyer in the town of Maycomb. Their different professional backgrounds shape their perspectives and influence their approaches to justice.
2. Setting: Juror 8 is serving as a juror in a criminal trial, whereas Atticus Finch is the defense attorney for Tom Robinson, a black man accused of in a racially-charged Southern town during the 1930s. The different settings and contexts provide distinct challenges and obstacles for each character.
3. Personal Connections: While both characters exhibit empathy and compassion, Atticus Finch's personal connection to Tom Robinson as his legal counsel and advocate for justice adds a deeper layer to his involvement in the case. Juror 8, on the other hand, does not have a personal connection to the defendant in 12 Angry Men.
4. Family Dynamics: Atticus Finch has two children, Scout and Jem, and plays a significant role as their father figure. This aspect of his character shows his commitment to teaching his children about fairness, equality, and the importance of standing up for what is right. Juror 8's family dynamics are not explored in 12 Angry Men.
5. Impact on the Narrative: In To Kill a Mockingbird, Atticus Finch's role as the central character allows us to see his journey and the consequences he faces in fighting for justice. In contrast, Juror 8's character in 12 Angry Men is part of an ensemble, where the focus is more on the collective process of reaching a verdict and the dynamics among the jurors.
These are just a few key differences between Juror 8 and Atticus Finch. By considering these points, you can expand on your comparison of the two characters.
Certainly! To compare and contrast Juror 8 from "12 Angry Men" to Atticus Finch from "To Kill a Mockingbird," you can consider the following differences:
1. Context and Setting: Juror 8 is a member of a jury in a criminal trial, whereas Atticus Finch is a respected lawyer in a racially tense town during the 1930s.
2. Personality and Temperament: Juror 8 is initially calm, soft-spoken, and level-headed, while Atticus Finch is generally more reserved and reflective. Finch exhibits a quiet and thoughtful demeanor, whereas Juror 8 is more assertive and passionate in his beliefs.
3. Motivations: Juror 8 is driven by his belief in the importance of a fair trial and justice. He advocates for taking the time to thoroughly examine the evidence. On the other hand, Atticus Finch is motivated by his moral convictions and his desire to stand up for what is right in the face of racism and injustice.
4. Roles and Responsibilities: While Juror 8 fulfills his civic duty as a juror, his responsibilities are somewhat limited to the case at hand. In contrast, Atticus Finch is instrumental in defending Tom Robinson, a black man falsely accused of , and he plays a major role in helping his community confront its underlying prejudices.
5. Impact and Influence: Juror 8, through his persistence and integrity, manages to convince the other jurors to reevaluate their initial assumptions. He challenges their biases and leads them to a more fair and just decision. Atticus Finch, on the other hand, uses his skills as a lawyer to challenge societal norms and inspire others to think critically about their own beliefs, ultimately leaving a lasting impact on his community.
To find more differences, you can further explore the characters' actions, relationships with others, and the overall themes and messages conveyed in each story. Also, consider analyzing the specific scenes or dialogues where the characters' differences are elucidated.
Read through these and other websites you might find which analyze these two characters. You might get some ideas from the ones below and others in your own searches (Google, Bing, Ducksters, etc.).
https://www.sparknotes.com/lit/mocking/character/atticus-finch/
and
https://study.com/academy/lesson/juror-8-in-12-angry-men-character-analysis.html
and
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twelve_Angry_Men#Characters
Scroll down and read the brief description of Juror #8.