I am very lost on this one can anyone please help me? In this scenario, how would you conduct a stakeholder impact analysis using the stakeholder impact analysis approaches methods: moral standards and 5-question? The mayor of a small seaside town faces a tough decision. A prominent developer has submitted a proposal to build a large mall and resort in the town. This development is estimated to bring $150 million in tourism each year and several hundred new jobs to the community, which badly needs the economic boost. The proposed location of the new development, however, is a site that now houses the only nursing home and senior citizens’ recreation center in the area. Both the nursing home and recreation center would have to be demolished, affecting 100 seniors and 30 employees. There is no other location in town where the new development can be built. How should the mayor decide: in favor of economic prosperity or in defense of his elderly citizens?
P.S.
1. The mayor knows the group involved, has identified them and made a list.
2. What is the desired outcome? He'll never make everyone happy!
3. With a petition/survey he'd have those for and those against.
4. Obviously he knows th e barriers/concerns. These elders and seniors can not be thrown out with no place to go.
5. How badly does this town need jobs, income, etc.
6. What actions would you take, if you were the mayor?
Sra
To conduct a stakeholder impact analysis using the moral standards and 5-question approaches, you would follow these steps:
1. Identify the stakeholders: In this scenario, the stakeholders include the mayor, the developer, the seniors in the nursing home, the employees of the nursing home and recreation center, the local community, and potentially other businesses and organizations that may be affected.
2. Apply the moral standards approach: The moral standards approach involves assessing the impact of a decision on various moral principles or ethical standards. In this case, you would need to consider the moral principles of utilitarianism and justice. Utilitarianism focuses on maximizing overall happiness or well-being, while justice considers fairness and equality.
- Utilitarianism: Determine the overall happiness or well-being that would result from each decision. Consider the economic prosperity that the mall and resort would bring to the community, as well as the potential job creation and increased tourism revenue. Balance these benefits against the negative impacts on the seniors and employees who would lose their homes or jobs.
- Justice: Evaluate the fairness or equity of each decision. Consider the rights and interests of the seniors and employees who would be affected by the demolition of the nursing home and recreation center. Also, consider if there are alternative options that could be explored to minimize the negative impact on these stakeholders.
3. Apply the 5-question approach: The 5-question approach helps in understanding and evaluating the stakeholders' perspectives and interests. Ask the following questions for each stakeholder group:
- What are their interests, concerns, and rights? Consider the desires and needs of the seniors, the employees, and the local community. For example, the seniors may value their current living arrangements, while the employees may rely on their jobs for income.
- How will they be affected by the decision? Assess the potential impact on the seniors, employees, and the local community if the mall and resort are built on the current site. Identify the specific consequences and how they align with each stakeholder's interests.
- Can their concerns be minimized or addressed? Explore possible alternatives or measures that could mitigate the negative effects on the seniors and employees. This could involve finding alternative locations for the nursing home and recreation center or providing compensation or support for the affected individuals.
- How would the stakeholders prioritize the decision? Consider how each stakeholder group might prioritize economic prosperity versus the well-being of the elderly citizens. This would require understanding their values and priorities.
- What decision would be fair and just? Evaluate which decision would most align with principles of fairness, equity, and justice considering the overall consequences and impacts on all stakeholders.
After considering these approaches, the mayor would need to weigh the potential economic benefits against the negative impacts on the seniors and employees. It is crucial for the mayor to seek input from all stakeholders, consider alternative solutions, and make a decision that is fair, just, and considers the overall well-being of the community.