Physics

Here’s how two different students approached part A.

Elizabeth: Since the little brother is half as heavy as her sister, he must sit twice as far from the pivot in order to “compensate” for his lower weight—6 feet instead of 3 feet.

Jill: I used the formula for torque, Torque = Fr, where F is force and r is distance from the pivot. Here, the
relevant forces acting on the see-saw are gravitational, the weights of the children: F1 = 60 pounds and
F2 = 30 pounds. The big sister sits r1 = 3 feet from the pivot, and we’re solving for r2. The torques
must balance: F1r1 = F2r2. I plugged in the numbers to get (60 pounds)*(3 feet) = (30 pounds) * r2, and
solved for r2 to get 6 feet.

1. The two students got the same answer. Did one (or both) of them get lucky, or are both kinds of
reasoning valid? Explain.

2. Are Jill and Elizabeth’s reasoning fundamentally the same, fundamentally different, or a mix of those two extremes? Explain

  1. 👍
  2. 👎
  3. 👁
  1. Elizabeth used correct logic and was able to do the problem "in her head" by reducing the problem to its essentials. Zero net torque requires equal and opposite torques on opposote sides.

    The reasoning of both is fundamentally the same.

    1. 👍
    2. 👎
  2. how

    1. 👍
    2. 👎
  3. both are the same

    1. 👍
    2. 👎
  4. What is answers for this question.

    1. 👍
    2. 👎

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. physics 1

    A brother and sister are standing next to each other at rest on a surface of frictionless ice. The brother’s mass is exactly twice that of his sister’s. The sister suddenly pushes her brother. As a result, the sister moves

  2. Math, NEEDS HELP EMEDIETLY!

    Q: Marissa Is researching information about martial arts students. She found that 7 out of 12 martial arts students practice each day. there are 144 students at her school. Part A: Predict how many students practice every day.

  3. Maths

    Out of 28 students,12 HV at least one brother.and 13 HV at least one sister.eight student have both sisters and brother s.how many students do not have either a brother or a sister.

  4. Math Check!

    Elizabeth has two identical number cubes. Both cubes have faces numbered 1 through 6. If Elizabeth rolls each cube once, what is the probability that the sum of the two numbers on the top faces will be 10? •1/36 •1/12 •1/10

  1. 3 other questions.

    Sorry. Elizabeth wants to turn her diary entry into a fictional short story. Which BEST identifies a structural change that would allow readers to know more about the thoughts and feelings of Stevie and Elizabeth's parents?

  2. PreCalculus

    I need help with a Matrix Algebra problem A small school has 100 students who occupy three classrooms A, B, and C. After the first period of the school day, half the students in room A move to room B, one-fifth of the students in

  3. algebra

    Homer is giving some cookies to each of his three brothers. To the oldest, he gives half of the cookies and half a cookie. He then gives half of what is now left and half a cookie to his second brother. Finally, he gives half of

  4. MATH

    Q: Marissa Is researching information about martial arts students. She found that 7 out of 12 martial arts students practice each day. there are 144 students at her school. Part A: Predict how many students practice every day.

  1. read

    1.Mr. Collins says he is proposing to Elizabeth because A. Elizabeth personality will displease lady Catherine B.Elizabeth has shown her affection for him C. he knows Elizabeth will inherit a lot of money D. as the heir, he feels

  2. Math

    The score for half of the students in a class on a certain test was 90. The score for another fourth of the students was 84. if the average (arithmetic mean) score for all of the students was 82, what was the average score for the

  3. Algebra

    In a school of 464 students, 89 students are in the band, 215 students are on sports teams, and 31 students participate in both activities. How many students are involved in neither band nor sports? A.160 students B.191 students

  4. Math

    Elizabeth asked 40 students at her school to name the first kind of pet they ever had she made the circle graph below to display the responses How many more students on dogs then on cats as the first pets 3 7 9 12

You can view more similar questions or ask a new question.