The critics Cleanth Brooks and Robert Penn Warren have said that Bierce's story depends too much on a quirk of human psychology and is thus a mere "case study" that does not reveal anything important about human nature, as good fiction does. Do you agree? Why or why not?

Question

The critics Cleanth Brooks and Robert Penn Warren have said that Bierce's story depends too much on a quirk of human psychology and is thus a mere "case study" that does not reveal anything important about human nature, as good fiction does. Do you agree? Why or why not?

disagree because this story took us on a journey with a man who was dead the whole time. We got to discover what was most important to him and we understood that everything became more distinct to him. That gave us insight to what type of person he was and his nature.

Answer 1

Additionally, the story also explores themes of pride, regret, and isolation, which are universal aspects of the human experience. By delving into these themes, Bierce's story does reveal important insights about human nature. The twist ending also serves as a commentary on the nature of reality and perception, adding depth to the narrative. Overall, while the story may have a central quirk of human psychology, it still manages to provide meaningful reflections on human nature.