The Swallow and the Pumpkinseed," the story centers around two
brothers who have differing approaches to life and nature. The younger brother, full of
compassion and kindness, nurtures a wounded swallow back to health and plants a
pumpkin seed that yields great riches. In contrast, the older brother
'
s jealousy leads to
harmful actions that result in a chaotic and humbling experience.
The younger brother
'
s act of kindness towards the injured swallow demonstrates his
caring nature and deep connection to the natural world. Through his nurturing efforts,
he not only saves the swallow but also reaps the rewards of the magical pumpkin that
grows from the seed he plants.
Conversely, the older brother
'
s envy and desire for similar wealth lead him to harm
the second swallow, which in turn brings about negative consequences. His actions stem
from jealousy and a lack of appreciation for the blessings that already exist in his life.
The theme of brotherhood is central to the story, showcasing the bond between siblings
and the impact of their actions on each other,compassion and forgiveness. Through the
younger brother
'
s example of kindness and generosity, the older brother learns the
error of his ways and seeks reconciliation, ultimately realizing the importance of
appreciating and celebrating the success of others.
Overall, "The Swallow and the Pumpkinseed"
serves as a poignant reminder of the
transformative power of empathy, forgiveness, and the enduring strength of familial relationships
can you redo this info with using this info Exceeds
(4pts)
Meets
(3pts)
Developing
(2pts)
Insufficient
Evidence
(1pt)
Draft #1
Comments
Thesis/
Introduction O Begins with a
compelling introduction
or lead.
O Includes a THESIS
STATEMENT at the
end of the first
paragraph.
O Rephrases and
answers the question
in the prompt including
supporting ideas.
O Begins with a lead
O Includes a THESIS
STATEMENT
O Rephrases and
answers the prompt,
but does not include
supporting ideas.
O Lacking a lead to begin
essay
O Attempts to include a
thesis statement, but
may not be relevant or
on topic.
O Attempts to rephrase
and answer the
prompt, but is not on
topic and/or relevant.
O Lacking a lead
O Does not have a thesis
statement
O Does not rephrase
and/or answer the
prompt
Pts: 3
Feedback: This intro
is a fabulous start!
One suggestion would
be to clearly
communicate the
theme.
Organization O TDA follows a strong
organizational
structure and focuses
on the task with
logically grouped and
related ideas,
including an effective
introduction,
development, and
conclusion
O Appropriate
organizational structure
and focus on the task
with logically grouped
and related ideas,
including a clear
introduction,
development, and
conclusion
O Weak organizational
structure and focus on
the task with
ineffectively grouped
ideas, including a weak
introduction,
development, and/or
conclusion
O Minimal evidence of an
organizational structure
and focus on the task
with arbitrarily grouped
ideas that may or may
not include an
introduction,
development, and/or
conclusion
Pts: 2
Feedback: Great job
attempting multiple
paragraphs. Your
paragraph breaks are
not clear and are
confusing to the reader
quotations from the
passage (Cite text
evidence) and an
explanation for each
piece of evidence in
each body paragraph)
quotation from the
passage with a clear
explanation for the
evidence.
but lacks a connection
to the TDA and/or an
explanation of the
evidence used.
from the text and/or an
explanation to connect
the text to the prompt
Feedback:No attempt
at direct quotes
Analyzing Text O Explains the evidence;
thorough explanation of
cited evidence and
why that evidence
supports your thesis
(answer).
O There was an attempt
to explain the evidence
used, but there was
nothing to tie the
evidence back to the
thesis.
O There seems to be an
explanation, however, it
is too vague or is
simply a summary of
the evidence used.
O There is no explanation
of the evidence used
Pts: 2
Feedback: You offer
some analysis that
explains a theme.
There is no attempt at
explaining direct
quotes.
Summarizing
Text
O Summarizes main
ideas; extends beyond
a restatement of
introduction.
O There is a summary,
however, it is simply
restating the
introduction.
O There is an attempt at a
summary, however, it
does not sum up the
paper because it
introduces new ideas or
is off topic.
O There is no summary of
the text.
Pts:2
There is a
summary of the text,
but it is not developed
and repeats
introduction.
Feedback: Your summary is a good start, but make sure to tie it back to the overall theme and message of the story. Also, try to extend beyond just restating the introduction.
can you write it
"The Swallow and the Pumpkinseed" tells the tale of two brothers with contrasting approaches to life and nature. The younger brother's compassionate nature is highlighted when he nurtures a wounded swallow and plants a pumpkin seed that yields great riches. In contrast, the older brother's jealousy leads to harmful actions and chaotic consequences.
The younger brother's kindness towards the injured swallow showcases his deep connection to the natural world and his ability to show compassion. Through his nurturing efforts, he not only saves the swallow but also reaps the rewards of the magical pumpkin that grows from the seed he plants.
Conversely, the older brother's envy and desire for wealth lead him to harm the second swallow, resulting in negative consequences. His actions stem from jealousy and a lack of appreciation for the blessings already present in his life.
Central to the story is the theme of brotherhood, illustrating the impact of siblings' actions on each other and the importance of compassion and forgiveness. Through the younger brother's example of kindness and generosity, the older brother learns the value of appreciating others' success. Ultimately, the story serves as a poignant reminder of the power of empathy, forgiveness, and the enduring strength of familial relationships.