Thomas Malthus

In the assignment I'm doing, there's a question that asks for whether Thomas Malthus believed in evolution or not. I don't know what to say considering he never made any direct references to it. I know he was a Reverend so I'm thinking he believed in creationism but I don't want to assume anything. Any suggestions?

asked by Lena
  1. I'd say the question wasn't applicable. Malthus died 25 years before Darwin published The Origin of the Species.

    posted by Ms. Sue
  2. Thank you Ms. Sue. The question also asked about Earth's history. So I'm thinking that is about how the Earth was formed and such. Malthus didn't make an references to that either so I would say the same about that as well?

    posted by Lena
  3. You are right about assumptions.

    Here is his first law:
    "Elevated as man is above all other animals by his intellectual faculties, it is not to be supposed that the physical laws to which he is subjected should be essentially different from those which are observed to prevail in other parts of animated nature."

    That speaks to what we see as the processes involved in what we call as Evolution.

    Here is all we have of his Religious Beliefs on the subject:
    "The powers of selection, combination, and transmutation, which every seed shews, are truly miraculous. Who can imagine that these wonderful faculties are contained in these little bits of matter? To me it appears much more philosophical to suppose that the mighty God of nature is present in full energy in all these operations."
    That is something nearly all Creationists would accept.

    Perhaps Malthus is being a blend of God's work as understood by man, and not relying on literal belief in the first chapter of Genesis,but more inclined to see that work as a psalm of creation. With that view, then
    "Malthusian selection is not proposed in opposition to the theory of evolution, but in support of it. In the context of new species, or the evolution of species, natural selection and artificial selection remain unchanged.

    However, in the context of populations, natural selection and artificial selection can now be seen in a new light, as additional group selection processes that work in conjunction with Malthusian selection to affect differential rates of reproduction for populations of all species" That is from http://academia.wikia.com/wiki/Malthusian_Selection

    which I anticipate you spending 10 minutes reading. If you do that, you will be more of an expert on the subject than your teacher, I anticipate.

    posted by bobpursley
  4. Thanks a bunch bobpursley :D

    posted by Lena
  5. http://members.optusnet.com.au/exponentialist/Malthus_Evolution.htm

    IS somthing else you might want to scan, it has some nice snippets on what you are asking .

    posted by bobpursley
  6. Thanks :D

    posted by Lena

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Thomas Malthus

    Thomas Malthus was a clergyman so is it safe to say that he did not believe in anything opposing the bible? Is it safe to say that as a firm believer in faith, he was certain that God created the Earth and the life on it? What can
  2. ~~~~~College Algebra

    Question: Various models have been used to make projections of growing populations. Thomas Malthus made one of the most famous conjectures of such a model in the early 19th century. Within Malthus’ claim was that the population
  3. geography

    What are 2 reasons why some geographers today believe Thomas Malthus' theory cannot be used to predict future population issues? Explain. What are 2 reason why some geographers today belies Thomas Malthus' theory can be use to
  4. Environmental Science

    what did Thomas Malthus believe
  5. History

    Based on Common sense and the crisis what conclusion can be made about Thomas Paine? A : Thomas Paine accepted blame for causing the war B: Thomas Paine believed that colonist should remain loyal to the king C : Thomas Paine used
  6. Geography

    4. Which of the following is not a reason why populations rise in particular places? A. Globalization and Capitalism B. Imperialism and Colonialism C. Famine and Drought D. Mercantilism and Industrialization E. Modernaization and
  7. Economics

    Thomas Malthus’s gloomy predictions for the future of humanity led ‘economies’ to be called a ‘dismal science’. Show either through the mathematics of production functions or intuitively, that predictions of such gloom
  8. sociology

    Which economist, using exponential growth, predicted that the world population would pass the capacity the planet could support? A. Jean-Baptiste Say B. Roy Forbes Harrod C. Sir John Richard Hicks D. Thomas Robert Malthus ughhh i
  9. Biology I

    Charles Darwin- Evolution? 2) Where does variation occur within an organism that causes evolution? 5) What is the main source of evidence for evolution? 6) What was the occupation that Darwin was originally studying for? 8) What
  10. Language Arts

    Thomas: Come on, Patrick you'll have fun. You'll learn alot, and you'll be helping a family have a home that they otherwise couldn't afford. Patrick: I don't know, Thomas. I've never built anything before, much less a house.

More Similar Questions