How does the image “Reversing Manifest Destiny” represent the negatives about manifest destiny, & trying to reverse these things? Identify & explain at least 2 details to help support your belief… (topic sentence & at least 1-2 supports)
How does each of these images represent different versions of hope? (topic sentence & at least 1-2 supports)
The image "Reversing Manifest Destiny" represents the negatives about manifest destiny and the efforts to reverse these negative outcomes. One detail in the image that supports this idea is the depiction of Native American figures reclaiming their land from white settlers. This reversal of land ownership highlights the unjust displacement and marginalization of indigenous peoples that occurred as a result of manifest destiny. Another detail in the image is the juxtaposition of industrialization and nature, with factories and smokestacks overpowering lush landscapes. This serves as a commentary on the environmental destruction and exploitation of natural resources that accompanied the push for westward expansion. Overall, the image portrays a stark contrast between the destructive consequences of manifest destiny and the push to rectify these wrongs.
The image of Native American figures reclaiming their land represents a hopeful vision of justice and reconciliation. It symbolizes the hope for restitution and healing for indigenous communities who were historically marginalized and displaced as a result of manifest destiny. The act of reclaiming their land signifies a desire to restore and revitalize cultural heritage and connection to the land, representing a positive vision for the future.
On the other hand, the image of industrialization overpowering nature presents a contrasting version of hope. It reflects the hope for environmental preservation and sustainability in the face of historical exploitation and destruction of natural resources. The juxtaposition of factories and lush landscapes serves as a call to action to prioritize environmental conservation and protect the Earth for future generations, offering a hopeful vision for a more harmonious relationship between human development and the natural world.
If I were living during the era of Manifest Destiny, I would feel conflicted about the idea that the US was "Destined by God" to spread across the continent. While there may have been a sense of excitement and opportunity in the belief of expansion, I would also be wary of the moral implications and consequences of such widespread territorial acquisition. The concept of Manifest Destiny, as articulated by John O'Sullivan, exemplified a sense of cultural superiority and entitlement that could justify the displacement and mistreatment of indigenous peoples.
Additionally, events such as the California Gold Rush further complicate the notion of divine destiny by highlighting the role of greed and exploitation in the westward expansion. The sudden influx of settlers in search of gold led to conflicts with Native American tribes, environmental degradation, and social unrest, challenging the idea of a righteous and benevolent spreading of US influence. Similarly, the Gadsden Purchase, which saw the US government acquiring land from Mexico in order to build a transcontinental railroad, raises questions about the ethical implications of territorial expansion through force and negotiation. Overall, while the idea of Manifest Destiny may have held promise and potential for economic growth and advancement, it also revealed darker aspects of conquest and imperialism that would give me pause and prompt me to question the true motivations and repercussions of such ambitious expansion.
Paragraph Question: If you were living during the era of “Manifest Destiny”, how would you feel about the idea that the US was “Destined by God” to spread across the continent?
In a 5-6 sentence response, explain your feelings about this, making sure to include at least 2-3 supporting details (evidence) including the ideas of John O’Sullivan, & 1 other event such as the CA Gold Rush, pioneers moving west on the Oregon Trail, or the Gadsden Purchase.