Simulated Trial Portfolio Instructions
Directions: For this portfolio, you will create a jury's verdict based on information
provided in an imaginary court case.
Step 1
Choose a fairy tale or other children's story on which to base the elements of your
case. For example, you could use "Goldilocks and the Three Bears," which would
serve to furnish an outline for a criminal case or civil suit. List the characters who
will be involved in the criminal or civil case. Tell what incident in the story the trial
will cover.
Step 2
Decide if the trial will be a criminal case or a civil suit. For example, Goldilocks
could be sued in a civil case for damages done to the Bear family's belongings, or
Goldilocks could be charge in a criminal case with burglary. On the other hand, the
bears could be charged in a criminal case with attempted murder. Explain why the
case is either criminal or civil.
Step 3
After deciding on what type of case, decide what evidence will be introduced by the
prosecuting attorney or the plaintiff. Decide what evidence will be offered by the
defendant's attorney. Be sure to include what witnesses will be called and what
evidence they will provide.
Step 4
Put yourself into the juror's role and decide what the verdict will be. For example,
will you find Goldilocks guilty of burglary? Explain how the burden of proof was met
by the prosecuting attorney and the evidence leads to a guilty verdict. Will you find
Goldilocks liable for the damages she inflicted on the bears' property? How much
money will she be required to pay the bears, if she is liable? Or, if the bears are
guilty of attempted murder, how did the evidence show their guilt?
Step 5
Complete the portfolio worksheet to submit for a grade. Make sure that you have
clearly outlined the information for your criminal or civil case
and have provided a well-reasoned verdict based on the evidence presented in the case. Be sure to use proper legal terminology and reasoning in your analysis.
Portfolio Worksheet:
1. Fairy Tale/Children's Story: Goldilocks and the Three Bears
Characters Involved:
- Goldilocks
- Papa Bear
- Mama Bear
- Baby Bear
Incident Covered in Trial:
- Goldilocks breaking into the Bear family's home and causing damage to their belongings
2. Type of Case: Civil Suit
Explanation:
- Goldilocks will be sued in a civil case for the damages done to the Bear family's belongings
3. Evidence:
- Prosecuting Attorney/Plaintiff:
- The broken chair and porridge evidence left behind by Goldilocks
- Testimony from the Bear family on the damages caused to their home
- Witness testimony from neighbors who saw Goldilocks enter the Bear's home
- Defendant's Attorney:
- Goldilocks' testimony claiming innocence and lack of intent to cause harm
- Character witnesses who testify to Goldilocks' good nature
4. Verdict:
- In this case, I find Goldilocks liable for the damages she inflicted on the Bear family's property. The burden of proof was met by the prosecuting attorney through physical evidence left at the scene and witness testimony. Goldilocks will be required to pay the Bear family for the damages caused, totaling $500.
5. Conclusion:
- The evidence presented in the case clearly showed that Goldilocks was responsible for the damages caused to the Bear family's home. The verdict of liability and the monetary compensation awarded to the bears is a fair resolution in this civil case.
1000 word limit
Introduction:
Goldilocks and the Three Bears is a classic children's story that has been enjoyed by generations. However, in this simulated trial portfolio, we will delve deeper into the story and explore the legal implications of Goldilocks breaking into the Bear family's home and causing damage to their belongings. The trial will be a civil suit, with Goldilocks being sued for the damages she inflicted on the Bear family's property.
Evidence Presented by the Prosecution:
The prosecuting attorney will present several pieces of evidence to support their case against Goldilocks. First and foremost, they will present the broken chair and evidence of Goldilocks' consumption of the Bear family's porridge. These physical pieces of evidence clearly show that someone had broken into the Bear's home and caused damage to their belongings.
Additionally, the Bear family will testify about the damages caused to their home. Papa Bear will recount how he found his favorite chair broken and Mama Bear will describe the mess left behind in the kitchen. Baby Bear will also provide his account of the events, detailing how his porridge was eaten and his room was disturbed.
Furthermore, the prosecuting attorney will call on witnesses from the neighborhood who saw Goldilocks enter the Bear's home. These witnesses will testify to seeing Goldilocks near the Bear's property on the day in question, further linking her to the crime.
Evidence Presented by the Defense:
In response to the prosecution's evidence, the defense attorney will argue that there is reasonable doubt as to Goldilocks' guilt. Goldilocks will take the stand and testify that she had lost her way in the woods and stumbled upon the Bear's home. She will claim that she only entered the home to seek shelter and food, not with the intent to cause harm or steal.
The defense will also call character witnesses to testify to Goldilocks' good nature. These witnesses will recount instances where Goldilocks had shown kindness and empathy towards others, casting doubt on the idea that she would purposefully harm the Bear family.
Verdict:
As a juror in this case, after considering all the evidence presented by both the prosecution and the defense, I find Goldilocks liable for the damages she inflicted on the Bear family's property. The burden of proof was clearly met by the prosecuting attorney through the physical evidence left at the scene, the testimony of the Bear family, and the witness accounts placing Goldilocks at the scene of the crime.
Goldilocks' testimony, while attempting to portray her actions in a sympathetic light, does not negate the fact that she caused harm to the Bear family's home. The character witnesses presented by the defense, while highlighting Goldilocks' positive traits, do not provide a valid defense for her actions on the day in question.
The damages caused by Goldilocks must be rectified, and as such, I find that she should be required to pay the Bear family for the damages caused. Considering the extent of the damages and the inconvenience caused to the Bear family, I determine that an appropriate sum for compensation would be $500.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, the evidence presented in this civil suit clearly shows that Goldilocks was at fault for the damages caused to the Bear family's property. The verdict of liability and the monetary compensation awarded to the bears is a fair resolution in this case. This trial serves as a reminder that actions have consequences, and individuals must be held accountable for their behavior, even in the context of a beloved fairy tale.
300 word ltmit
Introduction:
In this simulated trial based on the story of "Goldilocks and the Three Bears," the court is tasked with determining the liability of Goldilocks for the damages caused to the Bear family's property. The trial will be a civil suit, with Goldilocks being sued for the harm inflicted upon the Bear family's home.
Evidence Presented by the Prosecution:
The prosecuting attorney will present key pieces of evidence, including the broken chair and evidence of Goldilocks' consumption of the Bear family's porridge. Testimony from the Bear family detailing the damages caused to their home, as well as witness accounts from neighbors who saw Goldilocks near the Bear's property on the day of the incident, will further support the prosecution's case.
Evidence Presented by the Defense:
The defense will attempt to cast doubt on Goldilocks' guilt by arguing that she entered the Bear's home seeking shelter and food, not with the intent to cause harm. Goldilocks will testify to her innocence, supported by character witnesses who will attest to her kind nature.
Verdict:
After carefully considering all the evidence presented in the case, I, as a juror, find Goldilocks liable for the damages she caused to the Bear family's property. The burden of proof was met by the prosecution through physical evidence, witness testimonies, and the Bear family's account of the damages incurred. Therefore, I believe that Goldilocks should be required to compensate the Bear family for the damages, with an appropriate sum of $500 being awarded.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, the verdict reached in this civil suit serves as a reminder of the importance of accountability for one's actions. The resolution of this case highlights the need for individuals to take responsibility for the harm they cause to others' property, even in the context of a fairy tale narrative.