Any discussion about the treatment of native Americans by the federal government around this time here is Chief Joseph's speech. I'm tired of fighting our Chiefs are killed looking Glass is dead to Toohulhulsote is dead the old man are all dead it is a young man to say yes or no he who led the young men is dead it is cold and we have no blankets the little children are freezing to death my people some of them have run away to the hills and have no blankets no food no one knows where they are perhaps freezing to death I want to have time to look for my children and see how many I can find maybe I should find them among the Dead hear me my Chiefs I am tired my heart is sick and sad from where the sun now stands I will fight no more forever

Question

Any discussion about the treatment of native Americans by the federal government around this time here is Chief Joseph's speech. I'm tired of fighting our Chiefs are killed looking Glass is dead to Toohulhulsote is dead the old man are all dead it is a young man to say yes or no he who led the young men is dead it is cold and we have no blankets the little children are freezing to death my people some of them have run away to the hills and have no blankets no food no one knows where they are perhaps freezing to death I want to have time to look for my children and see how many I can find maybe I should find them among the Dead hear me my Chiefs I am tired my heart is sick and sad from where the sun now stands I will fight no more forever

Address the following prompt do you think you would have agreed with Chief Joseph if you were one of the Chiefs to whom he was speaking? Why or why not in one paragraph support your points with evidence

Answer 1

I believe I would have agreed with Chief Joseph if I were one of the Chiefs to whom he was speaking. His speech reflects the suffering and hardship experienced by his people, particularly the women, children, and elderly who were left without basic necessities like blankets and food. Chief Joseph's words convey a sense of exhaustion and hopelessness after their long fight against the federal government, highlighting the need for peace and a chance to care for their loved ones. His decision to no longer fight is rooted in a desire to protect his people and preserve what remains of their community, showing a strong sense of compassion and responsibility towards his tribe. Ultimately, Chief Joseph's plea for peace and the well-being of his people resonates with a sense of humanity and dignity that I would have found compelling as a Chief in his position.

Answer 2

Evidence to support your decision

Answer 3

One piece of evidence supporting my decision is Chief Joseph's acknowledgment of the dire conditions his people are facing, including the lack of blankets, food, and the freezing of the children to death. This demonstrates his deep concern for the well-being of his tribe and the urgency of their situation. Additionally, his statement "I want to have time to look for my children and see how many I can find, maybe I shall find them among the dead" shows his emotional turmoil and the heavy toll that the conflict and harsh conditions have taken on his people. Chief Joseph's emphasis on finding and caring for his vulnerable community members rather than continuing the fight reflects a compassionate and pragmatic approach that aligns with my belief in prioritizing the safety and welfare of the tribe.