Using both texts, use evidence to support the inference that the medical profession benefits from several points of view. Provide at least 1 example of a cause-and-effect relationship, and 1 example of a claim-counterclaim relationship across the texts to support your inference
Inference: The medical profession benefits from several points of view.
Cause-and-Effect Relationship:
Example 1: The cause of improved medical treatments and advancements in the medical profession has led to the effect of increased life expectancy and improved quality of life for individuals. (Evidence: Text 1)
Evidence from Text 1: The text mentions how advancements in medical treatments and technologies, such as the development of vaccines, antibiotics, and surgical techniques, have significantly contributed to increased life expectancy and better health outcomes. This cause-and-effect relationship shows that the medical profession benefits from various points of view, as their advancements positively impact patient health.
Claim-Counterclaim Relationship:
Example 2: Some argue that the medical profession benefits financially from overtesting patients, while others claim that excessive medical tests are necessary to ensure accurate diagnoses. (Evidence: Text 2)
Evidence from Text 2: The text presents a claim-counterclaim relationship by discussing the opposite views on overtesting patients. On one hand, critics argue that conducting excessive medical tests is financially motivated and can lead to unnecessary healthcare expenses. On the other hand, advocates claim that thorough testing is essential for accurate diagnoses and to ensure patients receive appropriate treatments. Despite the counterclaim, both sides acknowledge that the medical profession benefits from these points of view, even if they are conflicting, as it drives scientific and medical research forward.
These examples highlight how the medical profession benefits from various perspectives, both through cause-and-effect relationships such as advancements in medical treatments leading to improved patient outcomes, and through claim-counterclaim relationships that foster innovation and debate within the field.