Why does Thoreau not like beggars? How does this align with or contradict with Thoreau's other claims in the book?
Thoreau does not like beggars because he believes they perpetuate a culture of dependence and idleness. He criticizes the idea of seeking handouts instead of working for one's own sustenance and self-reliance. Thoreau argues that begging not only diminishes the dignity and independence of the individual but also creates an unhealthy dynamic within society.
This aligns with Thoreau's other claims in the book, particularly his emphasis on self-reliance and individual freedom. He promotes a lifestyle of simplicity and autonomy, urging individuals to rely on themselves rather than external forces. Thoreau believes that by working diligently and living frugally, people can provide for their own needs and avoid becoming dependent on others.
However, Thoreau's views on beggars can also be seen as contradictory to his argument against the societal structures that constrain human freedom. While he advocates for personal independence, he simultaneously condemns those who are unable to achieve this independence due to their circumstances. By criticizing beggars, Thoreau fails to account for the systemic barriers and inequalities that may prevent certain individuals from escaping poverty and becoming self-reliant.
Overall, while Thoreau's disdain for beggars aligns with his ideals of self-reliance and freedom, it also reveals a potential blind spot in his critique of society and his failure to fully consider the complex factors that contribute to human dependency.