You have read “Doris ‘Dorie’ Miller” and “Negro Hero,” a text and a poem about Doris Miller’s actions during the attack on Pearl Harbor. Using details from both the text and the poem, write an essay that analyzes the points of view of the author of “Doris ‘Dorie’ Miller” and the speaker in “Negro Hero.” In your essay, be sure to consider how the similarities and differences between the points of view of the author and the speaker impact the way the text and poem are told.
Write a well-organized, text-dependent response. Be sure to save time to edit and review your work for complete sentences, spelling, punctuation, and appropriate language. ! PARAGRAPH 1 PARAGRAPH
In both the text “Doris ‘Dorie’ Miller” and the poem “Negro Hero,” the author and speaker share a similar admiration for Doris Miller’s actions during the attack on Pearl Harbor. However, they express their points of view in different ways, which impacts the way the text and poem are told.
In the text “Doris ‘Dorie’ Miller,” the author portrays Doris Miller as a courageous and heroic figure. The author provides a detailed account of Miller’s actions during the attack, emphasizing his bravery and selflessness. For example, the text states, “He picked up a machine gun and began to shoot back at the enemy planes, even though he had never been trained to use the weapon.” This quote highlights Miller’s bravery in the face of danger, as he fearlessly took action despite his lack of training. The author’s perspective is clear: Miller is a true hero.
On the other hand, the speaker in “Negro Hero” uses poetic language and imagery to convey their admiration for Miller. The poem is filled with vivid descriptions that evoke strong emotions in the reader. For instance, the speaker refers to Miller as a “black thunderbolt,” implying that his actions were powerful and awe-inspiring. The use of figurative language in the poem adds a sense of grandeur to Miller’s deeds, further emphasizing his heroic status. The speaker’s point of view is evident: Miller is a remarkable and courageous individual.
While both the text and the poem share a similar view of Miller as a hero, the author and speaker differ in how they express this admiration. The text provides a more factual and objective account of Miller’s actions, focusing on the events that took place during the attack. In contrast, the poem conveys a more subjective and emotional response to Miller’s heroism. The speaker’s use of descriptive language and imagery creates a sense of awe and reverence for Miller’s actions. The differences in perspective between the two allow the reader to experience Miller’s heroism from different angles.
In conclusion, the author of “Doris ‘Dorie’ Miller” and the speaker in “Negro Hero” share a similar admiration for Doris Miller’s actions. However, they express this admiration in different ways, with the text providing a more factual account and the poem conveying a more emotional response. These differences in point of view impact the way the text and poem are told, allowing the reader to appreciate Miller’s heroism from different perspectives.