In this discussion, you will discuss the Hawaii Annexation.
Post a detailed response to the discussion prompt. Then comment on at least two other posts.
To understand how you will be graded for this assignment, read the Discussion Guidelines and Rubric.
Using your knowledge of the text and the sources given, answer the question:
Should the U.S. have annexed Hawaii?
The annexation of Hawaii by the United States is a contentious issue that has sparked debate and controversy. While some argue that the annexation was a necessary step for the United States' strategic interests and economic gains, others argue that it was a violation of Hawaiian sovereignty and self-determination.
One of the main arguments in favor of annexation is the strategic importance of Hawaii. At the time, Hawaii provided a strategically located naval base in the Pacific Ocean, which was seen as crucial for American military and economic interests. With the rise of the United States as a global power, securing Hawaii as a territory would ensure American control over a crucial strategic outpost.
Furthermore, the annexation of Hawaii was seen as economically beneficial for the United States. Hawaii had a thriving sugar industry at the time, and American businessmen had significant economic interests in the island. Annexation would allow the United States to have control over the sugar plantations and ensure favorable trade conditions.
However, it is important to consider the negative consequences of annexation. The annexation of Hawaii was not supported by the majority of the Hawaiian population. Queen Liliuokalani, the last reigning monarch of Hawaii, opposed the annexation and attempted to restore the power of the monarchy. Annexation was seen by many as a violation of Hawaiian sovereignty and self-determination.
Additionally, the tactics used to facilitate the annexation were questionable. The overthrow of the Hawaiian monarchy in 1893 was engineered by a group of American and European businessmen with the support of the United States government. The role of the United States in the illegal deposition of the Hawaiian monarchy raises concerns about the legitimacy of the annexation.
In conclusion, the annexation of Hawaii is a complex issue with valid arguments on both sides. While the strategic and economic benefits of annexation cannot be ignored, the opposition of the Hawaiian population and the controversial means used to achieve annexation raise questions about its legitimacy. It is essential to evaluate the historical context and consider the perspectives of both the American government and the Hawaiian people to fully understand the implications of the annexation.
In this discussion, you will discuss the Hawaii Annexation.
Post a detailed response to the discussion prompt. Then comment on at least two other posts.
To understand how you will be graded for this assignment, read the Discussion Guidelines and Rubric.
Using your knowledge of the text and the sources given, answer the question:
Should the U.S. have annexed Hawaii?