Question 1
How does Columbus’s description of the Caribbean islands reflect Spain’s motivations for sending him there? Hint: If Columbus had not had the goal of conquering land and resources, how would his observations have changed?
SENTENCE 1 - Answer
Columbus describes the islands as…
SENTENCE. 2 - Textual Support
We see this when the text states, “...
SENTENCE 3 - Explain
This shows that Columbus was thinking about… If he did not have the goal of conquering lands, Columbus’ descriptions may have been…
Question 2
Suppose Columbus simply had complete freedom to explore the world without specific goals in mind. How would that have affected his observations? How might it have affected world history? Hint: How might history have changed?
SENTENCE 4 - Answer
If Columbus had complete freedom to explore the world without worrying about any specific goals, his observations would likely have been about…
SENTENCE 5 - Details/Support
For example, Columbus would have been able to learn about…
SENTENCE 6 - Explain
This might have changed history by…
Question 1
SENTENCE 1 - Answer
Columbus describes the islands as rich in resources and potential for colonization.
SENTENCE 2 - Textual Support
We see this when the text states, "I saw that they were a people who could easily be made servants and convinced that they should convert to our Holy Faith more by love than force."
SENTENCE 3 - Explain
This shows that Columbus was thinking about subjugating the native inhabitants and exploiting the resources of the islands. If he did not have the goal of conquering lands, Columbus' descriptions may have been more focused on the natural beauty and peaceful interactions with the natives.
Question 2
SENTENCE 4 - Answer
If Columbus had complete freedom to explore the world without worrying about any specific goals, his observations would likely have been more scientific and focused on documenting new flora, fauna, and geographic features.
SENTENCE 5 - Details/Support
For example, Columbus would have been able to learn about new plant species, study different ecosystems, and map out geographical landmarks.
SENTENCE 6 - Explain
This might have changed history by advancing scientific knowledge about the world, leading to a more accurate understanding of geography and ecosystems. It could have also sparked interest in further exploration and colonization by other nations.
ok now put it all together and make sure it makes sense and it flows together nicely
Columbus's description of the Caribbean islands reflects Spain's motivations for sending him there. He portrays the islands as rich in resources and potential for colonization. In the text, Columbus states that he saw the native inhabitants as people who could easily be made servants and convinced to convert to Christianity. These observations show that Columbus was driven by the goal of subjugating the indigenous population and exploiting the resources of the islands.
If Columbus had complete freedom to explore the world without specific goals, his observations would likely have been more focused on scientific exploration. He would have been able to document new flora, fauna, and geographic features. Instead of viewing the native inhabitants as potential slaves, Columbus may have had more peaceful interactions with them, appreciating the natural beauty and cultural aspects of the islands.
This shift in Columbus's observations might have had a significant impact on world history. Without the drive for conquest and colonization, Columbus's discoveries and documentation of new lands and species could have advanced scientific knowledge about the world. This could have led to a more accurate understanding of geography and ecosystems. Additionally, Columbus's peaceful interactions with the indigenous people may have fostered cultural exchange and understanding. It could have sparked interest in further exploration and colonization by other nations, potentially shaping the course of history in different ways.