UNIT 11
Argument Analysis
LESSON 10
Portfolio: Present a Claim
For this portfolio entry, you will present a claim and provide an argument analysis. This will involve analyzing the strengths and weaknesses of an argument and evaluating its overall effectiveness.
To begin, you will need to choose a claim to analyze. This could be from a news article, a political speech, a commercial, or any other source that presents an argument. The claim should be clear and specific, and it should be something that you feel strongly about.
Once you have chosen a claim, you will need to analyze the argument that supports it. Identify the main points and evidence used to support the claim. Consider the reasoning and logic used in the argument. Are there any fallacies or logical errors? Is the evidence strong and credible?
Next, evaluate the overall effectiveness of the argument. Does the evidence convincingly support the claim? Are there any counterarguments or alternative explanations that the argument fails to address? Is the argument clear and persuasive?
In your portfolio entry, present your chosen claim and provide a detailed analysis of the supporting argument. Use specific examples and evidence to support your analysis. Make sure to address both the strengths and weaknesses of the argument. Conclude with your overall assessment of the effectiveness of the argument, and whether you find the claim to be convincing or not.