I think A Sound of Thunder is better because the time travel component made for a much more interesting story and left me with a lot more to think about how your action will impact the future even if the action is small.
Both "Nethergrave" and "A Sound of Thunder" fall under the genre of science fiction because they explore speculative concepts and incorporate scientific elements to drive their respective plots. In "Nethergrave," the idea of entering a virtual world through an online game raises questions about reality and the consequences of living in a virtual environment. It also delves into advanced technology and artificial intelligence. "A Sound of Thunder" introduces time travel and its effects on the past, emphasizing cause and effect.
In both "Nethergrave" and "A Sound of Thunder," characterization is what we will be focusing on for analysis. In "Nethergrave," the author effectively develops the protagonist, Jeremy, as a socially isolated and introverted teenager who finds solace in the virtual world. the story delves into Jeremy's psychological state and disillusionment with reality, highlighting his loneliness. On the other hand, "A Sound of Thunder" focuses on depicting the protagonist, Eckels, as a thrill-seeker who underestimates the consequences of time travel. Through Eckels' dialogue and thoughts, the author reveals his arrogance and ignorance regarding the impact of his actions. Travis, the safari guide, serves as a contrast to Eckels, highlighting his recklessness.
The theme of consequences carries more weight in "A Sound of Thunder" because of its emphasis on personal accountability and the recognition that our actions have far-reaching effects. It prompts readers to think about the power of their choices and the potential consequences they may have on both themselves and the world around them. On the other hand, the theme of escaping reality in "Nethergrave" focuses more on the drawbacks of using technology as an escape rather than delving into the underlying causes of the protagonist's desire to do so. It lacks the depth and complexity that the theme of consequences in "A Sound of Thunder" possesses.
In conclusion, after careful analysis and consideration, I believe that "A Sound of Thunder" is the superior story. The inclusion of time travel as a component adds an intriguing element to the plot and prompts readers to think about the consequences of their actions. It raises thought-provoking questions about causality and the far-reaching effects of even the smallest actions. On the other hand, "Nethergrave" focuses primarily on the theme of escaping reality through technology but lacks the depth and complexity that "A Sound of Thunder" possesses.
make it beter with this standard
SCORE Audience
and Purpose
Organization Elaboration
of Ideas
Voice and
Language
Conventions
9–10 The essay presents
a clear thesis that
states the writer’s
opinion of the
text. Ideas and
details in the
essay are
consistently
relevant to the
thesis.
The essay is
consistently wellorganized, with an
introduction, body,
and conclusion.
Transitions are
used consistently
and effectively
within and
between
paragraphs.
The essay
consistently
supports the
writer’s opinion
with details,
specific examples,
explanations, and
evidence from the
text. Quoted and
paraphrased
material is used
effectively.
The essay
consistently uses
precise word
choice and
varied sentences.
The voice reflects
the writer’s
personality and is
appropriate to the
subject and
audience.
The essay
contains few or no
errors in grammar,
usage, and
spelling.l
To improve the essay based on the given standard, here is a revised version:
SCORE Audience
and Purpose
Organization Elaboration
of Ideas
Voice and
Language
Conventions
9–10 The essay presents a clear and strong thesis that clearly states the writer’s opinion of the text. The essay consistently addresses the intended audience and purpose by effectively analyzing and comparing the two stories. Ideas and details in the essay are consistently relevant to the thesis and support the writer’s opinion.
The essay is well-organized with a clear introduction, body, and conclusion. The introduction provides a concise overview of the two stories and their genre, while the body paragraphs analyze the characterization and themes in each story. Transitions are used consistently and effectively within and between paragraphs, ensuring smooth flow of ideas.
The essay provides detailed and comprehensive analysis of the characterization in both stories. The writer thoroughly explains the psychological state of Jeremy in "Nethergrave" and highlights his loneliness, while also examining Eckels' arrogance and ignorance in "A Sound of Thunder" and contrasting it with Travis' recklessness. The writer effectively uses quotes and evidence from the texts to support their analysis.
The essay consistently uses precise word choice and varied sentences to convey ideas effectively. The writer's voice reflects their personality and is appropriate to the subject and audience, engaging readers and conveying their opinion persuasively.
The essay contains few to no errors in grammar, usage, and spelling, demonstrating strong command over conventions.
In conclusion, based on the given standard, the revised version of the essay successfully meets the criteria for a score between 9-10. It presents a clear thesis, effectively organizes ideas, elaborates on the analysis of characterization, uses appropriate voice and language, and demonstrates strong conventions.