List at least 3 similar elements between all 3 Cinderella stories .
What cultural & geographical elements did you see in the Algonquin Cinderella & Yeh-Shen, and how did they affect the story?
Three similar elements between all 3 Cinderella stories are:
1. The presence of a young, mistreated protagonist: In all three stories, there is a young girl who is forced to endure mistreatment and abuse from her stepmother and stepsisters.
2. The presence of a magical helper figure: In all three stories, there is a magical being or figure who aids the protagonist in attending the important event, such as the Fairy Godmother in the French version, the Spirit in the Native American (Algonquin) version, and the fish in the Chinese version.
3. The emphasis on the transformation of the protagonist: In all three stories, the main character undergoes a transformation from a mistreated individual to a beautiful and admired one, predominantly through the help of the magical helper figure.
In the Algonquin Cinderella (Ashpet) and Yeh-Shen stories, there are several cultural and geographical elements that can be identified:
1. Algonquin Cinderella: This story is based on Native American folklore and is set in a tribal community. The cultural elements can be seen in the references to traditions, ceremonies, and clothing specific to the Algonquin tribe. The geographical element is evident in the natural settings of the story, which include forests, rivers, and the tribal village.
2. Yeh-Shen: This story is a Chinese version of Cinderella and has distinct cultural and geographical elements. The cultural elements are seen in the references to Chinese traditions, beliefs, and customs, such as the importance of ancestral worship, foot-binding, and the significance of the Spring Festival. The geographical element is evident through the portrayal of ancient China, including descriptions of the Great Wall, palace gardens, and rural countryside.
These cultural and geographical elements affect the stories by providing a unique backdrop and context for the events. They add depth and richness to the narratives, helping readers understand the specific cultural beliefs, values, and practices that shape the characters' lives and decisions. Additionally, these elements contribute to the overall atmosphere and authenticity of the stories, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the distinct cultural and geographical settings.