Write a paragraph in which you explain how including a conflicting point of view and evidence in an argument can make it more persuasive. Describe the effect that including point of view and evidence can have on readers. Give specific examples.
6 sentences
Including a conflicting point of view and evidence in an argument can greatly enhance its persuasive power. When an argument acknowledges and counteracts opposing viewpoints, it shows that the author has considered all sides of the issue and is presenting a well-rounded analysis. This demonstrates intellectual honesty and can enhance the author's credibility. For example, if someone is making an argument in favor of stricter gun control laws, addressing the argument that it violates the Second Amendment right to bear arms demonstrates a willingness to engage with opposing views. By providing evidence to refute this opposing viewpoint, such as statistics on gun violence or examples of successful gun control measures in other countries, the author strengthens their argument by showing that they have thoroughly considered all perspectives.
Including conflicting viewpoints and evidence can also have a significant impact on readers. When readers encounter an argument that acknowledges and addresses opposing viewpoints, they are more likely to trust the author's expertise and consider their argument objectively. This can lead to greater engagement with the ideas presented and a deeper understanding of the topic. For instance, if an author is making a case for the benefits of social media in fostering interpersonal connections, but also acknowledges and counteracts the argument that social media can lead to isolation, readers are more likely to trust the overall argument. By presenting evidence of studies that demonstrate the positive effects of social media on relationships, the author can persuade readers to view social media in a more positive light.
Incorporating conflicting viewpoints and evidence in an argument allows readers to see a comprehensive analysis of the topic. It demonstrates that the author has considered multiple perspectives, which can aid in building trust and credibility. By addressing opposing viewpoints head-on and presenting evidence to refute them, the author can strengthen their own position and make a more persuasive argument overall. Giving readers the opportunity to evaluate the argument from multiple angles fosters critical thinking and encourages a more nuanced understanding of the topic.