"Perfectly Imperfect” WHEN VARIATION IS THE KEY TO SUCCESS by Donna Bozzone.
The portfolio must include the following:
One paragraph in which you analyze the text structure of the informational text. Identify the text structure. Explain how you identified it. Tell how the author’s choice of structure helped you as a reader.
One paragraph in which you analyze the author’s purpose and point of view. Explain how you determined the author’s point of view. Tell how thinking about the author’s purpose and point of view helped you to understand the topic.
One paragraph in which you analyze how the author distinguished their position from other positions. Explain what you learned from thinking about the different positions. Give examples from the texts.
In the informational text "Perfectly Imperfect" by Donna Bozzone, the text structure is clearly a cause and effect structure. The author presents a problem, which is the focus on perfection in society, and then provides various examples of the negative effects this can have on individuals and society as a whole. The author uses specific instances to illustrate how the pressure for perfection can lead to anxiety, stress, and even mental health issues. The cause and effect structure helps the reader understand the negative consequences of the perfectionistic mindset and supports the author's main message to embrace imperfections.
The author’s purpose in "Perfectly Imperfect" is to challenge the unrealistic standards of perfection that society often imposes on individuals. The author's point of view is clear throughout the text, as they argue against the detrimental effects of striving for perfection. By presenting examples and discussing the negative consequences, the author aims to persuade readers to shift their perspective and embrace imperfections. Considering the author’s purpose and point of view helped me understand the topic by highlighting the importance of self-acceptance and the damaging effects of striving for an unattainable ideal.
Throughout the text, the author distinguishes their position from other positions by providing contrasting viewpoints and presenting them as flawed. For example, the author acknowledges that some may argue that perfectionism leads to success and should be encouraged. However, they counter this argument by presenting evidence of the negative consequences, such as decreased mental well-being and increased stress. The author also highlights the benefits of embracing imperfections, such as increased creativity and resilience. By presenting these different positions and ultimately debunking them, the author solidifies their stance on the importance of accepting imperfections. This helped me understand the topic by providing a comprehensive view of different perspectives and enabling me to critically evaluate the merits of each argument.