Mr. Joker drives home from a long day of shopping at the Waterfront Mall. As he
approaches his driveway, he notices his neighbour, Mrs. Y’s dog laying in front of his
4
gate. He knows that Mrs. Y has gone to visit her children out of town over the weekend.
Upon inspection of the dog, Mr. Joker finds it severely injured. He takes the dog to the
vet to have it tended to and after paying the bill he takes the dog to his house to look after
it until Mrs. Y returns. Upon her return Mrs Y thanks Mr Joker. He provides her with the
bill from the vet, but she indicates that he decided to take the dog to the vet, so the bill is
his sole responsibility.
4.1 Which remedy is available to Mr. Joker. Motivate your answer
The remedy available to Mr. Joker in this situation is reimbursement for the vet bill.
Mr. Joker acted out of goodwill and took responsibility for Mrs. Y's injured dog by promptly taking it to the vet and bearing the costs of the necessary treatment. However, it is important to note that Mr. Joker did not have a legal obligation to do so, as the dog belonged to Mrs. Y and was injured outside of Mr. Joker's property. Mrs. Y's absence and the fact that the dog was injured in front of Mr. Joker's gate do not create a legal duty for him to care for the dog.
In this case, Mr. Joker can argue that he provided a voluntary service by taking the dog to the vet and incurring the associated expenses. He can present the bill as evidence of the amount he paid for the dog's treatment. By doing so, he can seek reimbursement from Mrs. Y for the costs he incurred due to her dog's injury.
It is important for Mr. Joker to document all the steps he took, including notifying Mrs. Y about the situation and her agreement or acknowledgment of his actions. This will further support his claim for reimbursement. Additionally, if there were any witnesses to the incident or individuals who can vouch for Mr. Joker's role in caring for the dog, their statements may strengthen his case.
In conclusion, the remedy available to Mr. Joker is to seek reimbursement for the vet bill from Mrs. Y. He acted out of goodwill in taking care of her injured dog, but he is not legally obligated to bear the sole responsibility for the cost of the treatment.