Both the Siege of the Alamo and James Fannin’s surrender at Goliad were important events in the Texas Revolution. Which of the following statements describes a similarity
between the Siege of the Alamo and James Fannin's surrender at Goliad in the Texas Revolution?
a) Both events occurred in the same year.
b) Both events involved Mexican forces defeating Texan rebels.
c) Both events resulted in the death of all Texan defenders.
d) Both events marked turning points in the outcome of the Texas Revolution.
A similarity between the Siege of the Alamo and James Fannin's surrender at Goliad in the Texas Revolution is that both events were significant conflicts that occurred during the same time period, with a similar outcome of Texian defeat and loss of life.
wrong
To determine which statement describes a similarity between the Siege of the Alamo and James Fannin's surrender at Goliad in the Texas Revolution, we need to analyze both events and compare their characteristics.
The Siege of the Alamo took place in 1836 when a small group of Texian (Texan) defenders held the Alamo mission against a large Mexican army led by General Santa Anna. The Texians fought valiantly but were ultimately overwhelmed and defeated, with only a few survivors.
On the other hand, James Fannin's surrender at Goliad occurred in the same year. Fannin and his troops were stationed at Presidio La Bahía in Goliad when they were surrounded and besieged by Mexican forces. After several days of resistance, Fannin eventually surrendered under the condition that his men would be treated as prisoners of war and spared. However, contrary to the agreement, Santa Anna ordered their execution, resulting in the infamous Goliad Massacre.
Now, let's consider the options and find a statement that highlights a similarity between these two events:
Option 1: Both events resulted in decisive victories for the Texians/Texans.
This statement is incorrect since both the Siege of the Alamo and James Fannin's surrender ended in defeats for the Texians/Texans.
Option 2: Both events involved the capture and imprisonment of Texian/Texan soldiers.
This statement is accurate. In both the Siege of the Alamo and James Fannin's surrender at Goliad, Texian/Texan soldiers were captured and held either as prisoners of war (as was initially promised for Fannin's men) or executed (as occurred with Fannin's men).
Therefore, the correct statement describing a similarity between the Siege of the Alamo and James Fannin's surrender at Goliad is:
"Both events involved the capture and imprisonment of Texian/Texan soldiers."