How does Whitman's attitude toward death in "Song of Myself" compare to Dickinson's attitude in "712: Because I could not stop for Death"?
A.
Whitman perceives death as an unexplainable phenomenon, while Dickinson believes that death can be explained.
B.
Whitman views death as cruel and sad, while Dickinson sees death as a mystical force.
C.
Whitman describes death as a relief from life, while Dickinson describes death as ruthless and unforgiving.
D.
Whitman sees death as a renewing the earth, while Dickinson views death as spiritual rebirth.
D.
Whitman sees death as renewing the earth, while Dickinson views death as spiritual rebirth.
To compare Whitman's attitude toward death in "Song of Myself" with Dickinson's attitude in "712: Because I could not stop for Death," you would need to analyze both poems and consider the viewpoints of each poet.
In "Song of Myself," Whitman discusses the cycle of life and death, and he often presents death as a natural part of existence. He emphasizes that death is mysterious and inevitable, stating, "Do I contradict myself? / Very well then... / I am large... I contain multitudes." This suggests that death is a complex concept that cannot be fully comprehended by humans. Whitman's poem reflects a sense of wonder and acceptance regarding the inevitability of death.
On the other hand, Dickinson's "712: Because I could not stop for Death" portrays death as a kind and patient companion. The speaker personifies death, describing it as a gentle guide throughout life's journey. Dickinson's attitude toward death is more accepting and even portrays it as a peaceful and comforting presence. She writes, "We slowly drove – He knew no haste / And I had put away / My labor and my leisure too, / For His Civility."
Based on these analyses, we can see that option D, "Whitman sees death as renewing the earth, while Dickinson views death as spiritual rebirth," is the most accurate comparison between the two poets' attitudes toward death. Whitman's view suggests that death is a part of the natural cycle of life and promotes the renewal of the earth through its occurrence. Meanwhile, Dickinson portrays death as a transformative and spiritual experience.
Thus, option D (Whitman views death as renewing the earth and Dickinson views death as spiritual rebirth) is the most suitable answer to the question.
D.
Whitman sees death as a renewing the earth, while Dickinson views death as spiritual rebirth.