Which of the following best describes why some Indians consider the Salt March a failure?(1 point)
Some Indians consider the Salt March a failure because the British declared war on India.
Some Indians consider the Salt March a failure because Indians still had limited power to govern themselves.
Some Indians consider the Salt March a failure because the protestors were beaten and arrested.
Some Indians consider the Salt March a failure because Gandhi resigned from the Indian National Congress.
Some Indians consider the Salt March a failure because Indians still had limited power to govern themselves.
To determine which of the options best describes why some Indians consider the Salt March a failure, we need to examine each statement and evaluate its relevance to the Salt March.
1. "Some Indians consider the Salt March a failure because the British declared war on India."
This statement is not directly related to the outcome of the Salt March. The Salt March was a nonviolent protest against the salt tax imposed by the British, and it did not directly lead to a declaration of war. Thus, this option is not the best description of why some Indians consider the Salt March a failure.
2. "Some Indians consider the Salt March a failure because Indians still had limited power to govern themselves."
This statement is a valid consideration when evaluating the impact of the Salt March. The objective of the Salt March was to highlight British injustices and the need for greater autonomy for Indians. While the Salt March gained international attention, it did not immediately lead to a significant shift in the power dynamics, which is a contributing factor as to why some Indians consider it a failure. Therefore, this option is a more appropriate description.
3. "Some Indians consider the Salt March a failure because the protestors were beaten and arrested."
This statement highlights a significant consequence of the Salt March. Many protestors, including Mahatma Gandhi, were indeed beaten and arrested by the British authorities during the march. However, while this event highlights the oppressive response of the British, it does not specifically address whether the Salt March is considered a failure or success. Therefore, this option does not directly explain why some Indians consider the Salt March a failure.
4. "Some Indians consider the Salt March a failure because Gandhi resigned from the Indian National Congress."
This statement may be a relevant consideration, as Mahatma Gandhi's resignation from the Indian National Congress in 1934 was a significant event following the Salt March. However, while this resignation influenced the subsequent course of events, it is not the primary reason why some Indians may consider the Salt March as a failure. Therefore, this option is not the best description.
Considering the above analysis, the second option, "Some Indians consider the Salt March a failure because Indians still had limited power to govern themselves," is the most accurate description of why some Indians consider the Salt March a failure. The limited impact on India's self-governance despite the widespread protest is a significant factor in this perspective.