Which of the following best describes the change over time in the relationship between Indigenous tribal governments and the U.S. government?(1 point)
Responses
Initially characterized by equality, their relationship is now more oriented toward the U.S. government.
Initially characterized by equality, their relationship is now more oriented toward the U.S. government.
Initially dominated by the U.S. government, their relationship is now more oriented toward equality.
Initially dominated by the U.S. government, their relationship is now more oriented toward equality.
Initially characterized by equality, their relationship is now more oriented toward Indigenous tribal governments.
Initially characterized by equality, their relationship is now more oriented toward Indigenous tribal governments.
Initially dominated by sovereign Indigenous tribes, their relationship is now more oriented toward equality.
Initially dominated by the U.S. government, their relationship is now more oriented toward equality.
Initially dominated by the U.S. government, their relationship is now more oriented toward equality.
To determine the best description of the change over time in the relationship between Indigenous tribal governments and the U.S. government, we can analyze the options given.
Option 1: Initially characterized by equality, their relationship is now more oriented toward the U.S. government.
Option 2: Initially dominated by the U.S. government, their relationship is now more oriented toward equality.
Option 3: Initially characterized by equality, their relationship is now more oriented toward Indigenous tribal governments.
Option 4: Initially dominated by sovereign Indigenous tribes, their relationship is now more oriented toward equality.
To find the correct answer, we need to consider the historical context of the relationship between Indigenous tribal governments and the U.S. government. The initial contact between Indigenous tribes and the U.S. government was marked by colonization, forced removals, and attempts at assimilation. The U.S. government often imposed its authority and laws upon Indigenous tribes, treating them as subordinate nations.
Option 1 suggests that the relationship has shifted towards the U.S. government over time, indicating an increase in dominance by the U.S. government. This option does not align with the historical context.
Option 2 states that the relationship has moved towards equality from initial dominance by the U.S. government. This is a more accurate description of the shift over time. Since the mid-20th century, there has been a greater recognition of Indigenous sovereignty and an effort towards self-governance and self-determination.
Option 3 suggests that the relationship is now more oriented towards Indigenous tribal governments. This option does not reflect the historical context accurately, as the U.S. government has historically exerted control over Indigenous tribal governments.
Option 4 indicates that the initial dominance was by sovereign Indigenous tribes, with a shift towards equality. While some tribes were indeed sovereign before colonization, the historical context of the relationship shows a domination by the U.S. government that lasted for many years before the movement towards equality.
Based on the analysis, option 2: "Initially dominated by the U.S. government, their relationship is now more oriented toward equality" is the most accurate and best describes the change over time in the relationship between Indigenous tribal governments and the U.S. government.