Which of the following is an example of helpful feedback that addresses a specific problem?
If you delete this section and shorten the introduction, your paper will not be as wordy.
I liked your paper and thought it was interesting.
This topic is boring. You should change it.
This paper is way too long.
If you delete this section and shorten the introduction, your paper will not be as wordy.
The example of helpful feedback that addresses a specific problem is: "If you delete this section and shorten the introduction, your paper will not be as wordy."
To determine which of the following is an example of helpful feedback that addresses a specific problem, we need to consider the content and relevance of each option.
Option 1:
"If you delete this section and shorten the introduction, your paper will not be as wordy."
This option provides specific guidance on how to address a concern, which is the wordiness of the paper. It suggests removing a specific section and shortening the introduction, which helps tackle the problem directly.
Option 2:
"I liked your paper and thought it was interesting."
This option does not address any specific problem nor provide any constructive criticism. It is a positive comment but does not provide the feedback that addresses a specific issue.
Option 3:
"This topic is boring. You should change it."
While this feedback does address a specific issue, which is the topic being perceived as boring, it does not offer any specific advice or suggestions on how to improve it. The feedback could be more constructive by providing guidance on alternative topics or suggesting ways to make the current topic more engaging.
Option 4:
"This paper is way too long."
Similar to Option 1, this feedback highlights a specific problem - the length of the paper. However, it does not provide any detailed recommendations or suggestions on how to resolve the issue.
Based on the analysis, Option 1: "If you delete this section and shorten the introduction, your paper will not be as wordy." is the example of helpful feedback that directly addresses a specific problem and also suggests a potential solution.