Use the passage to answer the question.

Question

Use the passage to answer the question.

Should cities be required to have detailed evacuation plans? In 3–5 sentences, answer the question and provide specific textual evidence to support your analysis.

(4 points)

Short Answer Rubric (4 points)
Points Awarded Criteria
4
The answer is very clear.

The answer is fully supported by details.

There may be a few errors in grammar, usage, or mechanics. Errors do not interfere with meaning.

3
The answer is mostly clear.

The answer is supported by mostly relevant details.

There are a few errors in grammar, usage, or mechanics. Errors do not interfere with meaning.

2
The answer is somewhat clear.

Details are weak or not related.

There are some errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics. Errors interfere with meaning.

1
The answer is not clear.

There are few or no supporting details.

There are many errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics. Errors interfere with meaning.

0 The question is not answered.
Many fire-prone California towns don’t plan for evacuations
Counterintuitive as it may sound, Paradise has some of the strongest evacuation planning in California. In fact, a USA TODAY Network-California survey of communities at high risk from wildfires found only 22% (including Paradise) have a robust, publicly available evacuation plan.

The scale of disaster in the Camp Fire was unprecedented, but the scene of people fleeing wildfires was familiar, repeated numerous times over the past three years up and down California from Redding and Paradise to Santa Rosa, Ventura, and Malibu.

In many of those communities, motorists became stuck in traffic as officials tried to evacuate thousands onto a few roads leading away from the flames.

NO REQUIREMENT TO PLAN

The 85 deaths and nearly 19,000 buildings destroyed in Paradise’s Camp Fire made it the deadliest and most destructive blaze in California history. Eight of those who perished were found in their vehicles, with two others found outside their vehicles.

In some spots, burned-out and abandoned vehicles lined roads leading out of town.

Answer 1

Yes, cities should be required to have detailed evacuation plans. The passage states that only 22% of high-risk communities in California have a robust, publicly available evacuation plan. The Camp Fire in Paradise resulted in 85 deaths and the destruction of nearly 19,000 buildings. The passage also mentions people becoming stuck in traffic as they tried to evacuate, with burned-out and abandoned vehicles lining the roads. These details illustrate the need for cities to have detailed evacuation plans in order to effectively and safely respond to emergencies.

Answer 2

The passage does not provide a direct answer to the question of whether cities should be required to have detailed evacuation plans. However, it does provide evidence of the consequences of not having such plans. The passage mentions that only 22% of communities at high risk from wildfires, including Paradise, have a robust, publicly available evacuation plan. It then describes the Camp Fire in Paradise, which was the deadliest and most destructive blaze in California history. It mentions that some of the deaths occurred because people were found in their vehicles or stuck in traffic while trying to evacuate. Additionally, burned-out and abandoned vehicles were found on roads leading out of town. This evidence suggests that detailed evacuation plans are necessary to prevent loss of life and property during disasters.