what is a good claim and good text evidence/reasoning for the remaining question “how does Alexander Hamilton’s letter support the way in which Lin-Manuel Miranda characterizes him in “Alexander Hamilton” ?
Claim: Alexander Hamilton's letter supports the way in which Lin-Manuel Miranda characterizes him in "Alexander Hamilton" as a determined and ambitious man who is unafraid to speak his mind.
Text evidence/reasoning: In the letter, Hamilton writes, "I have not eaten a better dinner than the one you were so kind as to give me," showing his gratitude towards the recipient. This aligns with Miranda's portrayal of Hamilton as a polite and grateful person, who acknowledges and appreciates the kindness of others. Additionally, Hamilton writes, "I have some scruples about troubling you with business," indicating his consideration for the recipient's time and workload. This supports Miranda's characterization of Hamilton as a thoughtful and respectful individual.
However, Hamilton also confidently expresses his opinions and beliefs in the letter, evident in his statement, "I must entreat your indulgence whilst I state to you my claim." This mirrors Miranda's depiction of Hamilton as a charismatic and outspoken figure who is not afraid to assert himself and his ideas. Thus, Hamilton's letter aligns with Miranda's portrayal of him as a determined and ambitious man with a strong sense of self and purpose.
A good claim for how Alexander Hamilton's letter supports Lin-Manuel Miranda's characterization of him in "Alexander Hamilton" could be:
The letter written by Alexander Hamilton reflects his ambition, intellect, and resilience, which mirrors the portrayal of his character in Lin-Manuel Miranda's musical.
Here is an example of text evidence/reasoning to support this claim:
In the letter addressed to George Washington on May 8, 1780, Hamilton's ambitious and determined nature is evident. He discusses his desire for advancement in rank, stating, "I am conscious that my military reputation stands on too precarious a footing to justify the request I am about to make." This shows Hamilton's relentless pursuit of recognition and success, which aligns with Miranda's portrayal of Hamilton as an ambitious and driven individual in the musical.
Furthermore, Hamilton's intellectual capabilities are highlighted in the letter. He references military strategy and presents a detailed plan to strengthen the Continental Army. Hamilton writes, "The advantage of compelling the enemy to enclose the whole of their works... would be very great." This demonstrates his analytical thinking and problem-solving skills, reinforcing Miranda's portrayal of Hamilton as a brilliant and strategic thinker.
Additionally, Hamilton's resilience is evident in his determination to persevere despite the challenges faced by the Continental Army. He writes, "We are now probably more exposed to a disappointment, than we have been at any time.... Our credit is almost gone, our horses are worn down, our chests are empty." Despite these obstacles, Hamilton remains undeterred and proposes solutions to overcome these difficulties. This resilience aligns with the portrayal of Hamilton in the musical, as he repeatedly faces adversity but never gives up.
In summary, the content of Alexander Hamilton's letter encompasses his ambition, intellectual brilliance, and resilience in the face of challenges, which supports Lin-Manuel Miranda's characterization of him in "Alexander Hamilton" as an ambitious, intelligent, and determined individual.